For the edible list:

The description says to take a swig of it.

I know that these items were just released, but the bags of grass seed should be edible.

(Anyone who has tried using them irl should know haha as I shoo away birds, deer, chipmunks, and squirrels)

Just posting a small update here:

This item has been removed from the suggestion list in the first post because it was recently made into a toy to go with the rest of its set, as per this forum topic.

I just received this item from Major Drills and didn't even know it existed before. I was surprised to discover it was not a minion; I think it should be one because this is.

looks like a book, so why not?

Because it's a wearable, unfortunately. They don't do items that are both books and clothes anymore, it's just one of the things they've decided on.

(also cute HA ^^)

I didn't notice that particular rule until I checked the first page of the thread, haha.

(And thank you! c:)

That's too bad. :( Now knowing that about the Spirit Photography Photo Album I can put my little stash into my shops and sell them.

minion-looking items holding food that you can steal and eat: and friends

minion-looking items holding food that you can't steal and eat:

please make them into food i would like to do crime

These should be wearable:

and

There's actually a separate thread for wearable suggestions - Make this item wearable

I think those items may have been suggested before there.

(also cool HA!)

Thanks for the link! For some reason I couldn't find it and thought this was the right one haha

And it's very much possible I've suggested these ones before XDD

Can this be made into food?

The descriptions imply that you can drink them.

If the items above are made edible, the remaining items in the set should be as well.

[Item=Romero Shipwreck Ambergris Tonic]

I want to drink this foul thing. Apparently you can try Ambergris ice cream IRL at some museum 😫

That's nasty, but okay I added it lol

First post should be updated to this point ~

The striped concoctions have already been rejected.

Oh, have they? They weren't on the list of rejected items that I had gotten from the old thread, and I don't remember if it was a long time ago. Maybe it got lost somewhere.

I'll leave them on the list for now though, because as pointed out, some of the descriptions do make them sound like they could be drinks.

shrugs The reason I remember it is because it was my Suggestion and I thought at the time the reasoning for rejecting it was weird. I agree with you the record of it has been lost, I can't find it either. We have been playing Subeta for a long time :)

I do think they should be drinkable, given the other odd things our pets can drink.

Make this a WEAPON. Its literally in the name! Make it a bomb-type weapon!