I've never really gotten why wearables can't be minions as well, since some become "companions" for our avatars, why can't they be companions for our pets as well? 😭

Unfortunately, that is just a rule that staff have decided on. I won't be putting any suggestions in the first post that break any of the guidelines we've been given just because I'm not a staff member so I don't have any authority on that.

If you would like to suggest a change of the rule, that would be better as a separate suggestion post because it would be up to staff to decide, not me.

The ones that show up on your HAs are not the same items unless some old items got grandfathered.. If you want them to work that way, you can make a separate Suggestion that it be allowed.

I noticed while reorganizing my vault that [item=gen. ecks flyer] is a book but is just a miscellaneous item. For reference, is a poster item that's also a book. :3

Can I eat this please? :c

[Item=Small Fighting Fish in a Bowl]

I suggest these. They are looking like minions:

I aslo like rift items and rift salad looks so alive:D. Please, I want it as a minion.

What are you thinking about other rift food? Should they be minions or not?

The garden gnomes already technically have minion forms?

The seeds also grow into a plant that produces a minion, so it feels a bit weird (to me at least) to have an item that would go minion, not minion, minion. -> ->

Yeah, since the first 3 already have separate minion forms, I might not add those. But I can add the rift items as suggestions. ^^

(just keep in mind this isn't a guarantee they will become minions, it's up to staff to decide when they look at this again)

Oh, thanks for letting me know.^-^ The Magical Watermelon Seeds are so cute. So I think it's sad, they don't have any use beside planting-.-

I know it isn't guarantee, but I would be nice to have more rift minions. Thanks for adding them. n_n

I'm not sure if this is ever mentioned, but is there a reason why

isn't readable? There are plenty of other items (csc unlocking challenger items) that you can read, but not this one,??

I'm not sure if there is a reason, but it is an older item so it may have just been overlooked. I'll go ahead and add it to the suggestion list, since it would make sense (to me) as a book/readable item.

Ah okay! I thought since it has been around for a while that it may have gotten rejected before.

Minion? [item2=toy ghost]

should be made into a minion and made edible. Otherwise, there is no real use for this item.

I think that battle invite is from an achievement, and all of the other battle invite items from achievements do not have other functions (Molten Summoning Tome Stage II, Gold Panzer Hydra Medal, etc.)

This is probably so battlers who read do not have to make awkward decisions between reading to their pet or summoning a challenger, since they are tied to achievements and technically only earnable once per account (though you can obvs buy them from a diff user)

That is a good point I didn't think of. I know there are other challenger summoning items that are readable, but as you said those are the ones sold in the Cash Shop or Millionaire Center, not the ones that only come from achievement prizes.

There are some in user shops right now, but if it was made into a book they would have to re-release it in some way most likely, since there don't seem to be many copies.

I'll go ahead and remove it from the suggestion list and keep this in mind in case it's suggested again. I know there are other books that come from achievement prizes, but since this item already has a use for summoning the challenger, it probably isn't a good idea to add a second use to an item that's one per account.

First post is up-to-date through this point.

Aww, now this is just mean. Why is this not edible? The description says it is!

Good catch!

I actually added that one to the list already on the first day, once someone pointed out it wasn't edible despite what the description said. I was hoping it would maybe be changed since it was brought up in the news post comments, but I'll leave it on the list at least and hopefully it can be changed in the future. :P

hopefully thank you for trying!