are edible, but are not.

Added the above.

First post is updated to this point ~

the two that are edible say they have some left in them from the description but the others do not say that in the descriptions. I believe I remember they said that is why they only made those edible but the others not.

I know that was something that users mentioned, but I don't remember if there was any official statement from a staff member on that.

I'll leave them as suggestions for now while we wait for an official answer.

I dont know if the following item has been mentioned to be made readable

The Vintage Bewitching Greeting Card could be made readable since it mentions greeting card in its name.

Those greeting card items won't be made into books because they're already wearable items.

thanks for letting me know!

edible?

Description suggests that ingesting it may have side-effects.

[Item=candy cane pin]

Even the description says it's edible~

The paint brushes remind me of the candy. I'd love if they were made edible.

This is the candy btw:

SPOILER (click to toggle)

I'm not sure which paint brushes you're referring to. It helps to put the actual item(s) in your post so I know what you mean. :)

My mistake. I meant these ones - https://subeta.net/user_shops.php/search/shops/Red+Paintbrush and the others. They're the brushes found in Home Appliances.

I'm not sure if I will add those to the list, just because they seem really unlikely to be made edible. They're just regular paint brushes, and there is no implication in the names or item descriptions that they are meant to be food as well.

If you would like to see an edible item (or items) similar to the candy you mentioned, it would probably be best to make a separate suggestion thread about it since it would make more sense as a brand new set of items.

based on description this maybe considered readable

description: Rumor has it that someone was eating ice cream and reading under the shade of the ikumoradeekanox one day, until they fell asleep. The tree absorbed both book and snack, and suddenly started growing this fruit!

All of the pullalong vultures are made from "Toy" alchemy tokens, and all of the other ones are indeed toys, but the black one isn't. I'm guessing that's just an oversight.

Oh, good catch! I added it with the explanation. :)

Please make this edible?

[Item=Bubbly Potion] Bubbly Potion

I just noticed that the Steamwork Turnip (a Steamworks Menagerie item from 2018) isn't edible, even though the Pickle Mechanic, an item from the same year, is both a minion and edible.

Ooh, good catch! I will add that to the list, since they've been making all of the other different turnips edible.

The first post should be up to date through this point ~