Hmm. Interesting. While I still think it's a shame, I can understand how some people might not understand what the item originated as. (Although, in the specific case of the Vehnam Shrug, I feel like this argument doesn't work since the item does not at all look like a companion/creature as a wearable -- it's a hood.)

Thanks for taking the time to explain further. Although I might not agree (especially in this specific instance), I can understand the reasoning behind it.

First post is updated to this point ~

You make a good point about the Carnivorous Fruit and I kind of agree, so I added it to the list to be reconsidered. We'll see what staff says when they look at this again.

Can this be added into Food and Minion categories?

Mushy Baby Pumpkin

Desc: Probably...shouldn't drink this.

Many things that already say don't eat/drink are actually edible, add in one more to the list?

My pet hungers

Looks delicious, permission to eat needed. xD

Book.

I mean we can read sketchbooks and blank composition books soooo.... lol!

Apologies if this is a repeat (it wasn't in the OP, but I didn't check the entire thread).

[item2=Greedy Pink Hermit Crab] would be a cute minion.

So surprised to see Pirrot Egg isn't listed to be made edible? Unless I missed it, but I swear, I read it 2x! Both posts!

[item2=Pirrot Egg]

I get that the overlay is a fully grown bird, but the item is very clearly a egg! The name is Egg. It's not hatching! And, really, what's more pirate that shoving this extremely valuable egg down Cibophobia's gullet??????

We can eat other pumpkins (carved or otherwise), so why not this one? Looks delicious to me :P

I agree the description says, "I hope you kept the seeds." Which they are edible.

One of the descriptions also says its warm, and I don't know about you but the smell of warm pumpkin would definitely make ME want to eat it lol

The seeds are what I love about pumpkins, I bake them every year with some salt. I love the smell of them as they bake.

The first post is updated to this point ~

Sorry for the late response, but the reason it's not a minion is because it's already a wearable and that's one of the rules that staff have decided on (no items that are both minion and wearable).

Yesss omg I wish I had some roasted pumpkin seeds right now. I have 2 giant pumpkins sitting in my kitchen waiting to be cooked down and pureed. This year I'll be baking my mom's pumpkin roll recipe and my grandma's pumpkin cookie recipe, as well as roasting the seeds. Can't wait! ^.^

I am thinking yummy recipes would it be possible for you to smail them to me. Right now I want pumpkin pie and roasted pumpkin seeds so bad, to bad we cant eat them year round.

for the edible list?

Thanks for looking at this thread again! I've updated the first post to remove the items that you mentioned already changing now.

I wanted to mention though again with the blub minions, all of the new ones released this year during Morostide have been edible, even the ones that aren't based on food items. So would it be possible to go back and make all of the other blub minions edible? Some of them already are, but some of the older ones not based on food items are not edible.

I could put together a list of the ones that are not edible later, if it makes it easier.

--x--

Also - See 's post above! Some items have had extra use options added to them, with possibly more coming later.

Yes, plans on making them all edible later! No need to put them all in the post. I'm just blanket making them an edible substance no matter how weird they are.