yeah i know we don't eat most seeds and that's probably why most of the seeds are not edible x) but birds eat various seeds, and we have bird pets, so... why not :p

Yeah true.

I guess we can see what they say about these ones, and then suggest some more for the next round if it goes over well. :P

Based on the "Chug it" in the item description and the wearable itself, seems like [Item=Contaminated Test Tube] should be edible.

could be minions. Some of the descriptions seem to suggest they are alive.

Those had been rejected before, but I went ahead and added them for reconsideration since you're right, they do seem like they could potentially be alive and be minions. Especially based on the descriptions.

[edit]Also added to the list, because other similar items are all minions but for some reason this one isn't.

Since we've been on a pie kick for making things edible, what about this one? [item2=Mystical Pie Amulet]

This fellow's description also mentions being made from candy, so how about him as well? [item2=Greedy Guts]

Also, the spice must flow. [item2=Hebenono Caterpillar]

While we're also talking edible gourds. [item2=Carved Jungle Gourd Souvenir]

And finally, the Holy Water item is already edible, so let me chug this one to. [item2=Shinwas Blessed Water]

is actually already edible, or at least it should be.

I added the other ones though. :)

Well that's what I get for not double checking. xD

I just saw in the news post, and I think it should be edible. Hopefully we can get a ruling on it before it retires.

Not sure if we will, since they've been busy with so many other things. But they usually bring the Delish sets back for things like the Black Friday sale or other special Cash Shop events and stuff. So it will likely be available again in the future, for people who would need it.

I went ahead and added all of the food gift items from that year's Delish sets. At least the ones could be food based on the names and descriptions.

one fireside side item I cant figure why its not edible since turnips are edible.

Haha, I was actually going to suggest that one myself when I saw it in the directory, but then I forgot. :P

Added now ~

Great minds think a like! I figure someone got busy when they set up all those items and only got to designate it as a minion.

The item should be made edible.

In case anyone missed it in the news comments, was made edible last night.

Just wanted to let y'all know, that's the only change for now though.

Also the first post is updated for suggestions up to this point ~

Thanks Laurey for keeping the OP up to date and looking over the thread ❤️

Thanks!

Thank you! :)

Thank you Laurey! <3

Thanks! I appreciate the announcement for reborn turnip.