I have no idea how you came up with that xD
Yay, congrats!
One last time so it doesn't get buried:
MY STEPS
-Sent [NPC] Mathis a friend request
-Befriended both Captain Cuddles and Incinerator with one pet (my T1, Morose)
-Gave that pet a Fish Bones minion (because that is what 's pet Makalu had for a minion, LOL)
-Made that pet my active
-Lost a battle to Prodigy (it may have taken a few battles, I was just mindlessly clicking, lmao)
I was also battling with just two Unadorned Steel Swords I had made over at the Asmodeus Lab, though neither of them broke during the battle that I unlocked him on.
I tried what Jess said worked and it did not work for me. So I looked at Makalu and changed one thing about my pet. As soon as I battled and lost after changing the one thing, I unlocked Mathis.
[flower=skrett]
Thanks for posting what you used.
You've found a Hidden Opponent!
Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
SPOILER (click to toggle)
I followed the friending steps and set my pet to active, but did not use the swords and still popped the challenger
I'm looking at Makalu...and I don't get it? They have flowers in their TC, and text, text, text, text in their profile...what is staring me in the face?
no friending required!
answer
I used from the news posts as my minion, I changed it to another dead thing the and that worked for , meaning there is more than one minion that will work :D
SPOILER (click to toggle)
I had the Zombie Kitten in my inventory yesterday and if I had just added it to a pet this would have gone so much smoother... 😂
Thanks . :)
I wish it was clearer exactly what is needed. How many of the steps taken are necessary?
Edit to add: Wrote this before I read Wesker's above post. xD
[flower=skrett]
- Oh my gosh, by chance I had a SPOILER (click to toggle)
Zombie Kitten
You've found a Hidden Opponent!
Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
thanks and
You Won! You have defeated Mathis 10 times! Mathis drops: Enchanting Dust You earned 3100 sP for beating Mathis! Cynde earned 1245 EXP Points!
Will go for the next 15 later. I need a headache tablet lol.
Okay, so my T11 battle pet has the zombie kitty, I used a spiral sword against Prodigy, I did the friending thing, and still nothing...do I just need to keep losing to Prodigy until he pops up?
thank you all for the tips! i promise i really am going to go do my tax return quiz now.
You've found a Hidden Opponent!
Mathis challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!
slooks like bad weather's in a bad mood with all these losses
mfw he finally pops up

the dead minion thing... doesn't make any sense to me. what, is captain actually captain cuddles II, in memoriam of captain cuddles I? who died eating bone-in fish fillet? i'm not even going to try and guess his fear, :U
SPOILER (click to toggle)
Yeah I was telling amber had someone not brought up that minion and the whole thing about abuse to cats, I would not have gotten that but then she told me there are multiple minions that work so it looks like all dead related minions will work
SPOILER (click to toggle)
My pet, Jackals, has a Skelot for a minion and I lost a battle with him yesterday. I wonder if it needs to be a cat-related dead minion?