Did you get the same loot every time? It could be loot-related. Maybe look for a weapon with one word that matches the loot or something?

I did all of that yesterday before the new shop went live I moved everything is was pretty easy as I didn't have a huge amount of items in my galleries and shop

I don't have a GA, I had over 30K unique items in one shop, and the site would frequently lag or crash before completing any operation. Not quite as easy, lol. Like I said,, tomorrow seems like a good day to continue that. Right now, supper sounds good. :)

I wonder if there was anything besides the Hikei Grooming Brush Shield in their armory when they used it...

Tier of pet (+ tier of weapon used?) + hour of the day? Iunno man, I'm grasping.

Well, she beat him with a t1 pet, a t1 weapon, and posted it around 1:46 PM. You could be onto something.

yea I dont blame you if I had that many items i would be wondering what to do with them all

Also, it could honestly be that it doesn't have to be a shield at all, but just a defense item.

I wondered if the loot could have to do with it, but I failed to make a connection. Maybe you'll have better luck, though!

I got (total): Leefhed x4 Loose Button Wreckage x1 Gold Rose Trinket x3

Well, the leefhed proves that it's not just random low-priced stuff. It might not have a connection to anything, but it's at least interesting.

I've used nearly all the T1 defense-only items and have had no luck :x If you'd like I could post all the items I've used so that you guys don't waste time on doubles

It might change, so even though somebody's used a weapon, it could still work for another person. But that could be useful anyway.

THIS TROLL. omfg. I had a very productive evening planned and instead I am buying random weapons based strictly on how hilarious they look

It can't have to do with tier, there's no 13th hour or t13 weapons.

"No 13th hour" sounds so wrong. YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN.

I took a look at my armory and I don't think I can justify putting ~118 items in a spoiler tag ^_^;

well it could, there are 12 tiers of weapons and 12 hours. it just would need to have nothing to do with your pet.

I meant the suggestion that all three had to be the same (I've seen this suggested multiple times already). It's no possible. As for time + weapon tier being the same, we've tried without success.

oh yeah, that definitely would not work :p I just think it's a random weapon from that tier, not any weapon. it could be a specific weapon that doesn't change, I'm not sure. I'll see tonight at 12 because I have 3/4 of the t12 weapons, someone will need to test out kwand.

I don't like the idea of it being random like that, it'd really fuck with peoples chances since so many aren't really obtainable or worth their price. Not to mention, doesn't it promote even more hoarding ? Gotta hoard all of the random weapons so I can maybe possibly beat this singular opponent if I am lucky to have the exact one and be on at a specific time.