I wouldn't like it either, but that's the only idea I can really think of that makes sense to me right now. yes it does! don't you know every time they tell us not to hoard they mean hoard even more? I hope it isn't the case, but we'll see.

I wouldn't be shocked, honestly. It's like how we kept getting told to not save so much sP. But then they price things like the Natasha, which doesn't just appeal to battle users but also wardrobe lovers, weapon collectors, and TC fans. And then there's the antique shop prices, which are great in theory but make things ten times worse.

it does seem like the solution to some of the problems is also the cause of those same problems. like let's stop hoarding by giving every item a use, so all of those items will now be worth more and get more expensive, so hoarders with stockpiles will get rewarded.

It could even be that they just pick one random weapon you can kill him with each hour and the 1/1/1 happened to be coincidence.

True, it could be a straight up random weapon. There are a lot of t1 weapons so probability of it being a t1 is pretty good.

I DID IT. I just started trying every single weapon in my armory and the Goldbrand worked! After 5, no more. So I believe it's probably just a random weapon that's chosen, and it changes once somebody beats him 5 times. :)

So I used:

At around 11:30 PM.

Pet:

Dante - Benedict

Stats: Level: 731 Health: 2767 / 3025 Strength: 1761 Defense: 1284 Speed: 1289 Intelligence: 1575 Tier: 10 Rank: 758

congrats!

I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's r1-99 restockable weapons. this sucks.

Has anything changed with the Troll? Or is it still random

Possibly! It might be a pattern if the next one turns out to be a t3 weapon, because the first was a t1, and mine was a t2.

Congrats, . I guess we just have to randomly keep trying.

This is honestly the most bullshit thing ever. Completely random restockable weapon that changes whenever someone gets 5 wins with it? Right....because everyone has all day to add every single restockable to their armory then play a guessing game.

Subeta: DON'T HOARD, THERE'S NO REASON TO HOARD Subeta: But also hoard because if you don't you'll miss out on achievements or spend all your sP trying to defeat a T1 challenger.

Make up your minds maybe?

it could be! who knows. either way, it's really annoying.

[edit] just got two wins then it changed. edit: nevermind, read below

Two wins?

Ah, so it's on a timer! Still, that's amazing, and congrats :) What weapon did you use?

You Won!

You have defeated The Troll 5 times!

You won a(n) Impossible token to use in the battle shop!

The Troll drops:

Cobble Stone Pile Carved Wood Troll Totem I Beat the Troll Tee Shirt

You earned 1 sP for beating The Troll!

Wuf earned 1 EXP Points!

actually nevermind, I had the wrong thing selected :p

was my item

I wonder if it's a specific item for each person? That changes every 5 wins?

NICE! Congrats!

I don't think so, because I tried the Goldbrand earlier when I had the "good" idea that maybe the weapons were chosen based on the loot you receive, and it didn't work. I think it's just random.

after your wins I went and bought the first page of r1-99 weapons that rs in weapon wearhouse, so I thank you for giving me some inspiration :P I just lucked out.

Haha! I only bought my Goldbrand because of some crack theory I came up with as well. Looks like all this speculation is getting us places.

what was your theory? :O

yeah that makes more sense to me than it switching for everyone. so it very well could be everyone gets assigned a different weapon for each group of 5 wins or something like that