I think it would be neat to add an option for the Loyalty Box of a CW Voucher. As a user it would appeal to me as much as the other options! Just curious if I'm alone in this thought.

Interesting, I'll throw my support behind this.

Edit: Yeah that is a fair point that Sopheroo makes, so scratch that.

The thing is that we can't sell the things we get from the loyalty box.

You can't sell treasure chests slots, name changes, gold account status, pet slots or pet colors, but you could sell the CW you get from the voucher

OOH what a great point you've made! I hadn't considered that!

I somewhat support this.

I do agree that makes a valid point, but is that necessarily a bad thing? I understand the point of making the loyalty box something that benefits your own account and can't be transferred. Would having one thing that you can profit from indirectly 'ruin' the intent of the gift? I think it would be worth discussing.

I have opinions on this that may get me in absolute crap with some people here so I'm just going to nod and say I support this with some adjustments (make the loyalty one non-tradeable, etc.)

I would support new options for the box, but not had transferable benefits.

Yeah, now I'm wondering if there's a way to make only the Loyalty CW Voucher not tradeable! That's a very good point.

I would support any CW or other wearable option. It is the one and also an important feature of the game which isn’t supported by the box.

I personally am struggling to care that a potential voucher item could be sold. We can profit from GAs and could make a pet for someone, use the potion on it, and then give it to them.

Even a neat wearable that ONLY comes from the Loyalty Box and is no-trade would be kinda fun!

Edit: Maybe like a costume box so people can choose their no-trade wearable.

CW vouchers are already untradeable. but that untradeability should absolutely NOT be extended to the item bought with the voucher. i'm not even sure if that would be mechanically possible to enforce.

i don't really see an issue with a loyalty reward being something you could theoretically "profit" off of, since the very nature of fungibility means you are gaining some monetary value from all of them to varying degrees. overlay totem = CSC you didn't have to spend on an overlay. treasure chest totem = you can sell any magical keepsake boxes you might have been holding onto for the same purpose. GA = more quests + autopricer + faster training = more sP. etc.

Thank you for the clarification about CW Vouchers, Frenchi! I agree it sounds pretty tough to make happen.

You cannot sell your Loyalty GA account itself, and you cannot sell pets. That's the difference.

If CWs in general were account locked, it would have been a brillant idea. But, they're not, so I can't really see it working. It sucks, because wearable people really do need a boon to go with the loyalty box - I just don't think that one is a good idea.

After all, why would wearable people allowed to profit from it, but no one else?

I would support something for wardrobe people, though. I just don't know what could be used

Preface: I am not a wearables person. My ha has seldom changed in over 5 years.

But what if it was like a one free skin unlock, or extra layer(is that a thing anymore?), increase in wardrobe size, one free hairstyle unlock?

It would be nice if shop size could be increased but I don't think that is a boon wearable people would like.

A skin unlock would be very cool!! There are a few that even as a long-time user I've had trouble unlocking. Or even a special Loyalty Box skin that only comes from that?

So, a miracle potion for skins? I could see an option to unlock a skin of your choice on site as being an option since there's so many. With loyalty boxes, there's a loyalty box every year after 2 years.. i.e. my next loyalty box is coming up in December so a one time skin I could see losing its novelty after the first time getting it.

Yeah I was thinking you get to make a choice from all the current skins. Like when everyone got to pick one in 2021 due to errors. So technically this is already coded. I know there are people out there that collect skins and with survival and morostide adding new skins yearly it would make it somewhat fresh choices. I was thinking like a Miracle Zapper or a Miracle Lotion (play on words here)

oh yes! Even though I'm getting very close to unlocking all the skins, I'm still lagging by 9 and doubt that I will ever get them all. This is something I might even be tempted to use over the GA. And it certainly solves the issue of being account bound.

It could also be a means to get the Ice skin which was event related and can no longer be acquired in any way.

I have very few skins, just bad at unlocking them but it’s a good option, so full support behind a skin unlocking boon.