I know we have a lot already but I'd still love to see some places come back for a time! Even if it may not happen right now.

For me I'd love to see the Epicon challengers make a comeback, you know the ones based off video games? Ping, Brain Eater and such.

Also of course, the Islanders from the ancient Pirates vs Islanders plot that feels like eons ago....

Oh and Lady of the Waters and Satyr of the Wilds!

I would love to see the Keel Hauliday challengers for achievements. I returned from a hiatus early 2022 and I don't recall seeing them in September of last year.

In addition, I'll take any and all return battle challengers. :*

As someone who has finally got into battling after being on this site well over a decade...all of them, tbh.

I need the Keel Hauliday challenger achievements too. Fingers crossed for next month!

As somebody who got into battling after all of these events, I would like as many of them back as they'll allow.

It would be cool to maybe get throwback challengers again next year or something. That was a fun way to bring some of them back for a limited time each month.

Yes of course Throwbacks would be amazing to see as well! ;___;

I also need the Keel Hauliday challengers to return this year. I'm 6 wins away from the last achievement. Got this one!

Crawbeast so I can get And this one! Thanks!

is more of a plot prize than challenger loot, but if Kiyo could somehow come back so I can complete my beanbag collection that would be great.

And I know this one is unlikely to randomly be brought back, and I'll just have to wait until the next gelly war, but I would love the Gelatin Wizards to appear so I can get that last achievement as well.

Pylots, always Pylots lol.

Slightly different but related. I would like to see more challengers in BQs. Whether from old plots or CS challengers or both. Variety is the spice of life. For the CS challengers could result in more purchases from the CS as people learn they can beat those challengers.

Oooh yes more options in BQs are also an awesome idea too!

I would absolutely loooove if Evil Morty could get rereleased. This challenger was awarded for participating in the 2018 Questathon and it would be awesome to be able to get it.

Maybe add it as another challenger that gets unlocked with a subscription account or recycle it as a Cash Shop challenger that shows up only on Black Friday if another questathon is not in the realistic future?

Surely there's some existing, fitting items that can be used for loot? As far as special loot goes, if it was replaced with regular loot, it wouldn't be a big deal imo.

Very cool.

This is a bigger lift and maybe not worth doing but it be neat if CS or Secret challengers could be noted while doing BQs. Like "X challenger is from November, if you like to battle them more you could buy them in November from the Cash Shop" or "X is a secret challenger. If you want to battle them outside BQs you could go find them hiding in the world of Subeta!".

For older challengers? Yes, a lot of those older ones have loot that's been rotated in and out as well as generic drops that chooses. That's why throwback challengers are pretty easy to bring back because we don't have to wait on artists to do new loot.

The challengers themselves are tagged by category on the backend, so theoretically it could be added in the text. I wouldn't be able to be as specific as the this was released in January of 2008 or anything, though.

Just saying Cash Shop or Secret under the challenger would be great. Maybe add a blurb to the main BQ page with what those things mean so people understand and are encouraged to look into it more.

Would definitely love Islanders this Keelhauliday along with the pirates and cruise ship dudes. Maybe have it be like a friendly rivalry with the islanders and pirates

Big "Yeah!" for throw-back-challengers!!!