[sup]Quote by [userid=605242] Ok, so I know I myself only would want to go to the Mystery box if it was restocking from a shop I know I would like. But I am sometimes too lazy or cheap to check it out each day or you know completely forget all together!
so why not have a thread and a ping group to let everyone know. Thank you everyone for being so supportive of this thread! It means the world to me! ❤ [/sup]
[sup] ⭐ NOTE **Anyone can ping the group that is in the group, and if we can keep pings to ONCE/TWICE a day. You guys don't have to wait for me to ping, anyone can ping if they wish to! I will just update the first post when I get the chance. I think if we pinged in the morning and in the evening that would work good. I always get sidetracked sometimes and forget. [/sup]
Link to Mystery Box? Click the large box down below in post 2
Click here to join Shops of the Mystery Box ping group
The ping is # mysterybox
[Spoiler=A huge thanks to...][/spoiler] [sup]Thank you to [userid=670601] for so much help! You can find [userid=670601]’s posts below with an incredible amount of information.[/sup]
[box=#E9ECEF]
[/box]
Location

Strategy
There are essentially three options for how to handle the Box:
[box=#E9ECEF]
[/box]
Important note
But let's play anyway!
My apologies to everyone who came here looking for a nice simple Mystery Box Guide ... no can do! But I promise it's not too hard to figure it out, or to find out.
The Mystery Box gives you the key information you need: which shop the items are coming from, and how much to pay. If you buy a few items and compare them (their hover info) with this, it should not be too complicated. It is a simple formula.
You may find that SubetaLodge helps you work it out. This particular link is for when the Mystery Box shop of the day is Philosopher's Store; you can select the other shops on the "Restock Location" dropdown list at the top right.
a simple example: click for screenshots
Going with my favourite shop, Spells Galore, here are some items I've had:
![]() |
|
![]() |
|
![]() |
👀 📊
Once you have worked it out, or if you fancy just trying your luck: information for each shop is given in the posts below.
Note: this is a work in progress!
useful threadsThe Giant List of Usability and Random Improvement 2.0 Comprehensive Guide to Battle Opponents (v2) [topic not found]
|
[topic not found] |
[CENTER]

Click to find out what shop is the Mysterybox for today.
| Click to find out what shops have been chosen this month.
| Click to find out what shops were chosen in previous years. |
| Shop | TLDR | Top five items | Detail |
| Accessory Bin | 1,046 items Wearables Link: Mystery Box | Accessory Bin1,046 items, IIRC all wearables | |
| All That Glitters | 247 items Wearables Off day; overpriced. | All That GlittersNo idea how, but just about everything in the shop is much cheaper in usershops. Today is not a Mystery Box day for me! | |
| Apocalyptic Apothecary | 816 items Potions, elixirs, stat boosters. Mystery Box | Apocalyptic Apothecary816 items, all for pet color/species and battling (one wearable). Low chance of finding something worth millions; high chance of finding something worth around 40-70k or <5k. Definitely a watch-the-numbers day if you're going to play. Stat boosters: Pets: Wearable: | |
| Atebus Shop | 378 items Wears, foods, books, collectables, etc Box | Atebus ShopQuote by Chocolate I believe the MB stocks rarity 1-99. Of course, seeing anything 81+ is going to be rare, especially in big shops.</p> <p>I&;m going to do a general breakdown of my own for this shop...The Smithy was great because there was a low amount of items (relatively), so seeing the r99 Key Mold was an actual possibility. To put things into perspective, Sable Smithy stocks only 28 items r1-99. Atebus Shop, stocks 335 items r1-99.Atebus Shop has an assortment of really high value items... However, next to 327 other items? Yeah, it&;s going to be hard to find them.I believe Pun&;s assessment is likely to be a "don&;t buy" day, just given the size of the shop. (Pun&;s note -- depends how much time you have; there&;s some good stuff.) However, if you were going to spend some time at the MB, here are some tips.Abandon all hope looking for Guide to Constellations.But seriously. Its shop price (736sp) is among the lowest in the shop, which means, even with MB&;s "pricing", it&;ll still be mixed in to the other 95% of the shop. I&;m not going to even bother adding that to my key-prices list. You could click all day and never get it.However, the rest of the items listed, have a chance of "catching your attention" if they appear in the MB. The item priced the lowest is The Stars of the Sky (4405sp). So, with its higher MB listing, it&;ll probably pop out a bit more. (And the other items, even more so.) Quote by pun Nebula Cola set released on 25th April 2018 Rad Tarts set released on 5th May | |
| Bake Stop | 440 items Foods, some for achievements Box | tbacopypasta | |
| Beach Shack | Box | Beach ShackQuote by jensen today&;s another off day, i think -- it&;s got roughly 700 items and of those, barely any are at/above 100k. ... unless someone can confirm that the box will cough up retired items? in which case i&;d love to go after all the bunny bubbles, assuming anyone knows their prices, but i really don&;t believe the box does retired items. | |
| Bean Me Up | Box | Bean Me UpIt's a huge shop, with 800+ items, so finding any one particular item is going to be not so much needle in haystack as needle in agricultural storage barn. Definitely a Buy All Over X day, depending on how much sP and time you have, and how dedicated you are to your Beanbag collection (or your Shop Till / Vault balance)!Best in show, from the first two pages of SubetaLodge: | |
| Bits and Bytes | Off day, cheap stuff | tbacopypasta | |
| Book Nook | Box | Book Nook430 items, all can be read to pets. Several achievement books. A very few are dual-function (also wardrobe). R99: [item=Our First Date...][item=The Horribly Bad Day!][item=UFO Sightings!][item=Why Pete and Hilary PWN!] Wearable: [item=Spot Spot!] | |
| Candy Shack | Box | tbacopypasta | |
| Carnival Stand | Box | tbacopypasta | |
| Cavern of Curios | Box | [item=Nimble White Art Print V.1] [item=Nimble Blue Art Print V.1] | tbacopypasta |
| Clothing Rack | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Defend and Conquer | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Food Market | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Get Mugged! | Wearable cocoa gifts! | shopcopypasta | |
| Grooming Parlor | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Half Baked | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Home Appliances | New wearables! | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Icy Goods | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Minions Market | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Music Shop | Don't play; cheap tat | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Paw Naturel | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Philosophers Store | Buy everything! | [item=alchemy token: wearable] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Plushie Parlor | Box | newest items [Item=Aqua Urubu Plushie][Item=Vibrant Urubu Plushie][Item=Lilac Urubu Plushie][Item=Golden Urubu Plushie][Item=Field Urubu Plushie][Item=Dusk Urubu Plushie] [Item=Dawn Urubu Plushie][Item=Cream Urubu Plushie][Item=Common Urubu Plushie][Item=Cherry Urubu Plushie][Item=Arid Urubu Plushie] [Item=Twilight Urubu Plushie][Item=Sun Urubu Plushie][Item=Silver Urubu Plushie][Item=Nuclear Urubu Plushie][Item=Marsh Urubu Plushie] | shopcopypasta |
| Quick Bites | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Rathskeller Inn | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Seedlings | One great item | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Sole Train | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Spells Galore | Buy everything! | SPELLS GALORESells: components for making battling Spell Scrolls at the Secluded Shrine, wearables, and foods (including some for achievements). This is @/pun's favourite Mystery Box shop!and many more So many good items, and everything is so cheap you can just mindlessly buy everything. Literally read a book while clicking, if you can position the cursor just right. | |
| Stick it to the Man! | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Sable Smithy | One good item Box | shopOne the one item is worth playing for. Lots of ~10k items in the shop, so if you play, buy with care or you'll spend a huge amount on cheap tat! | |
| Thimble & Co | Box | [item=][item=][item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Toy Box | Box | [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] [item=] | shopcopypasta |
| Trading Card Center | Box | shopcopypasta | |
| Weapons Warehouse | 406 items Weapons, wearables Box | Weapons WarehouseSome worthwhile items, but nothing madly exciting. Plenty of junky stuff that also comes from battle quests. | |
useful threadsThe Giant List of Usability and Random Improvement 2.0 Comprehensive Guide to Battle Opponents (v2) [topic not found]
|
[topic not found] |
[B]Welcome everyone to a shiny new MB thread! [User=pun] and I have been working to get the thread started. Some areas are still under construction.
Happy birthday ![/b]
July 16
The shop today is Philosopher's Store.
[B]Not sure as to which format we're going to go with so for tonight, here are both. One is basically a quick overview straight to the point. The spoiler still contains more detailed information. c:[/b]
| Shop | Notes | Best items |
| Philosophers Store | Buy everything! | [item=alchemy token: wearable] [item=alchemy token: book] [item=alchemy token: food] [item=alchemy token: bean bag] [item=alchemy token: plushie] |
[spoilertitle]
[/spoilercontent]
Thanks for the ping. New format looks interesting. :) Happy Birthday !
Formerly known as its_just_me
(I started in March)
Wine is the answer
What was the question?
Thank you
[flower=Senti]
I am not old. I am gracefully aged
Oooooo.... shiny new board! 🎉 Not sure which format I prefer- they’re both great!
Thanks for the ping! And Happy Birthday !
Name tag by Cyroris
Not all those who wander are lost ~ JRR TolkienHappy Birthday ! 🍨 🍰 💎 Thank you for the ping.
Thanks for the ping, and like the new format! :D Also happy birthday to 🍰 🎉
[center]
Please contact if selling these! (and other colors) (and other colors as well) Offering csc or will open my owned list for trades!
Happy New Thread! I Like the new format too! Very nice and ofc thanks for the ping :)
July 17
The shop today is Spells Galore.
28 - Spells Galore - buy everything
Spells Galore sells components for making battling Spell Scrolls at the Secluded Shrine, wearables, and foods (including some for achievements).
This is pun's favourite Mystery Box shop! So many good items, and everything is so cheap you can just mindlessly buy everything. Literally read a book while clicking, if you can position the cursor just right.
Thanks for the ping.
Formerly known as its_just_me
(I started in March)
Wine is the answer
What was the question?
Thank you
[flower=Senti]
I am not old. I am gracefully aged