I can't find an active thread for this (found several old ones), even though I thought there had been one semi-recently. If anyone has the link, please lemme know and I'd be happy to post it over there.

Some are definite needs for retirement, some are maybes or other issues (marked with * instead)

Basic -Forever Questing for Pets *Helper (Maybe - I seem to recall this mentioned somewhere as possibly not being awarded anymore due to GA beta testing) -Item Tag Helper -Snowball Champion *Snowball-ed (Maybe - if it's general too, but pretty sure it was meant to be/is event specific)

*RETIRED - Toy Supporter (Issue - See Candy Supporter below - these are in different sections)

Social *Attend a Subeta Meetup (Maybe - I know meetups are kind of an unspoken issue.. not sure if the achievement should remain in limbo or just be retired) *Raffle Winner! (Issue - should probably be updated to Forum Points, at least in the description)

*RETIRED - Linkback Buttons! (Maybe - The linkback buttons still exist, just double checking the achievement is still retired on purpose)

Items *RETIRED - Redeem a Raffle Ticket (Maybe - I thought part of the reason you can buy Raffle Tickets w/forum points is to get this achievement?)

Pets *Foodie (Issue - not working with Fancy Food for the first tier. This might not be fixable/you might just have to view the pet again, but still, jic)

Games *General Issue - Some Stocks achievements are retired (Diverse Portfolio, Stock Starter, Upwards Motion) some aren't (Stock of Value)

*Reading Drive Purchase (Maybe - I don't know if this works with the Antique Shop and I have no way to test it personally)

*RETIRED - Candy Supporter (Issue - See Toy Supporter above - these are in different sections) *RETIRED - Pumpkin King (Maybe - Pumpkin Collection is updated yearly, is this retired on purpose? Also arguably should go under Morostide) *RETIRED - Mallarchy Pond Mega Winner (Maybe - I don't remember what this used to be, but should it still be retired?)

Quests *RETIRED - Split Personalities (Maybe - on purpose?)

Collections *General Issue - the meta collection achievements aren't under here, but games? *General Issue - some say 'in your collection/album/x collection' some just say 'collect' which could imply inventory is ok + consistency *General Issue - some of the 'have a pet that has read' achievements are here, some are in Pets

*Full of Pride (Issue - Arguably belongs in Social)

Wardrobe *General Issue - The Lifelike Dolls could arguably use a sub-header

Subeautique *iNKorperated After Five (Issue - showing at the end/out of Alpha order - doesn't seem like lowercase should do that /shrug)

Layers

Battle -Fright Night (Arguably should be Retired under Morostide as well) -Pumpkin Punishment (Arguably should be Retired under Morostide as well) -Defender of Good -Don't hit yourself!

Seasonal *General Issue - Lots of goodie bag achievements here, lots in Items

Morostide -Mott Finder *Pumpkin Deleter (Issue - text is cut off)

*RETIRED - Shot in the Dark (Issue - could use some text explaining the interaction between it and The Quick and the Dead, maybe)

Luminaire -Melody Regular 2015

Atebus Revolution Masquerade -Defeat Hostile Model 1544-C -Defeat Mecharachnid

Vesnali *A World Of Birds (Issue - this should really go with the Bug Collection achievement in Items)

Omen Island Festival *General Issue - This should really be under Site Events, not Seasonal as it's not recurring

The Great Pandemic/Survival *Infection Expert (Issue - doesn't seem to be tracking progress)

*RETIRED - Mmmm Pastries (Maybe - similar to other old 'open' achievements, pastry boxes are still available for purchase) *RETIRED - Take a dose! (Maybe - the other Lockheart 'cure' achievements aren't retired (I don't think this cured me + Amoricone!!!), and this item is still buyable) *RETIRED - Zombie Den Regular (Maybe - retired on purpose? If so, update text perhaps?)

Legacy *General Issue - I know the title is meant to imply it, but shouldn't these all be under Retired? Perhaps at least the category title could become "Retired - Legacy", or get another layer to it (like Site Events)

Site Events *General Issue - Same as above/consistency since all the sub-categories here are all retired Not listing the categories, they are all fine.

System Issues:

• Achievements still often double on the page
• If you click 'Retired' header and there are no retired achievements in that category, it still has the same text as 'All' with no unretired achievements
• If you click on a specific achievement title you can't get back to the main categories without reloading the page
• Achievement name capitalization style is all over the place

If I missed any let me know (or if you remember better than I do / are willing to test anything testable out)!!

Rouland gets brought back every year.

Defender of Good Defeat Maleria the Dark Goddess in battle!

Dont hit yourself! Defeat Replika in battle .

those two also need retired.

Thank ya kindly, updated! I seem to remember some reference to Replika coming back somewhere (possibly when the current admins took over?), but all of it appears to be quite old or just people hoping for it, so no maybe :p

I haven't seen replika since I've been back so there's a good chance it should be retired. maybe it'll show up during a battle week or something :p I'm sure there are others but those are the two I knew off the top of my head

Yeah, it was more like 'her tech is still broken but we want to fix it/bring her back' but I can't even scrounge that post up anywhere (though it may be from the time that posts are now blanked, tbph). I'm good with a solid retire, for sure c:

i got both boudewijn achievements this masquerade, so i'm going to guess that those two don't need to be retired since he'll be back every year?

Thanks very much, fixed

Idk if the jaxon plot had enough achievements for its own category but it might be nice for it to have one since faded memories does? Two of those battle achievements would go there

[edit] some achievements were retired, but some were unretired, like Pumpkin King for collecting all of the pumpkins! if you needed that achievement but couldn't get it in the past, I think you get it on this page?

I have no idea if staff intend to bring this back or not but afaik Fantine's Pies was only around for one Fireside a few years back? (Category- Fireside, Achieve- Fantine Pies)

Oh, really? I completely missed it! I'll keep an eye out this November :P

Just, while you're here, is the Cursed achievement still available? Permanently retired? Hiding? It's not in the list anymore but it's also not in the retired list (the one for doing 1k quests each for Mori/Nori).

I am curious about the one that mentioned as well. It's been disabled for a long time, but I'm not really sure why. I wish it could be reinstated or something, because I had just gotten to 1k for each not long after it stopped working. :(

I think Grace removed it few months ago (we lost 2-3 achievements if you remember..) because after the achievements system revamp we got the meta achievement after doing one cursed quest..

Thank you!

I did not get the meta achievement and title from doing one quest. Not at any point actually - it was around for a long while and I was gaining progress on it as I gained progress on my Mori/Nori achievements - and then it just disappeared one day.

so probably it was some users, there was a day or two that you could get it and then they disabled it.. this is how I got it..

OK OK I have this achievement, it's not removed and also check the description

Split Personalities

Complete 1,000 quests for both Mori and Nori! You will earn this on your next quest with either Mori or Nori!

It's showing up in retired now for me =/ And still as something I don't have. They could've temporarily disabled it and removed it from the folks who got it during the glitch, then reinstated it after they solved the issue. It's a bummer that it's been retired without warning just because it was accidentally handed out.

I mean, Morostide Warrior was broken and it took them months to fix it, but they still were able to do so and retroactively hand it out to everyone who'd qualified.

the thing is that it was not accidentally given out.. if I remember right, there was a post on the forum by keith or grace that says that now we can get it by doing one quest and after a day or two it was disabled.. now it's retired because it was disabled since then..