I'd say getting the achievement without meeting the criteria counts as accidental - it's surely not on purpose!

I don't understand that at all - seeing as how I was actively doing quests for them during the time it disappeared. Everyone who was should have it then, and there's a lot of folks I know who quest frequently and didn't get it.

[edit] Also - folks who were definitely questing were not granted it, as one person was 1 day away from completing 1k for both of them at the time it was retired:

thread about it

The achievement description was updated after it became buggy and nobody could earn it and they added this: You will earn this on your next quest with either Mori or Nori!

So the "lucky" people did a quest and earned it + the title and as the description shows, the staff let it happen! and then they couldn't fix anything and it became a mess so they disabled it and after a while they retired it..

Okay, but my point still stands, people who were actively questing and completing Mori/Nori quests during the time you think this was changed were not awarded the title/achievement. So....I do not believe that's actually what happened, unless it was up for a one hour window only.

One of the people complaining in that thread had 1k for one of the questers and something like 985-990 for the other - and was actively going after that achievement. And then it was retired and they never got to complete it. So, if they did their quests on Day X and weren't awarded the achievement, and it was disabled on Day Y, that...doesn't add up to it actually being awarded after doing a single quest. Like, they did their quests, they didn't receive it, it was disabled before they could achieve it the correct way.

sure I'm not saying that you're wrong and I totally understand your point! :) I think they must find a solution and bring back this achievement, especially when now all the meta are working well.. I got the collections meta few weeks ago without any problem..

Okay, I was like...but I do not understand, I did quests and didn't get it haha.

Yeah, I would like them to re-add it since things seem to be working like they're supposed to now - other meta ones definitely are. Hopefully they can get it sorted otherwise I'll stop bothering to try and actually do Nori's quests (usually I quest at night so I'm always getting Mori).

I don't believe everything has been addressed. I know Amber was looking into the Cursed achievement and whether it was going to be reinstated and we never got an answer on that. I believe several others are outstanding still as well.