Ruin the wish of the person above you. Example: Person 1 - I wish I had a pony. Person 2 - Granted, but it appears inside your house and destroys all your furniture. I wish I could eat ice cream forever.
You get the picture. Ruin the wish of the person above you and then make your own wish. I wish I had a million dollars.
Granted, cost of living goes up 10,000%
I wish for nothing...
Granted, a world-destroying monster comes and destroys the planet, leaving nothing behind.
I wish for world peace.
Granted, humanity goes extinct.
I wish I could eat as much salsa as I want without getting a stomach ache.
Granted, but you eat too much salsa and start to hate it!
I wish I could fly.
Granted, but you get shot down by someone who thinks you're a cryptid.
I wish it didn't take me hours to fall asleep.
Granted, a hypnotherapist hypnotizes you to fall asleep when you hear a certain word. Unfortunately, they screwed up and that word is "the". You have to wear earplugs in public forever.
I wish I could time travel.
Granted, you can travel through time, but not space. Your time machine is in a fixed location, so when you travel back a week the earth is in a different place in its orbit and you die in outer space.
I wish I could talk to animals.
Granted, but you will not like what they have to say about humankind.
I wish...my time...were up...
Granted, but you have to start your life over again from the beginning and you can't change anything.
I wish drawing was easier for me.
Granted, but people start constantly asking for you to draw for them for "exposure" and not money.
I wish I could sing well.
Granted, but now you can only communicate in song which makes people really annoyed.
I wish I had some cookies.
Granted, you receive a gift basket full of amazing smelling cookies, but you're allergic to one of the ingredients!
I wish I could visit the International Space Station.
Granted, but you're completely untrained and end up messing up some important experiments.
I wish I had a high paying job.
Granted, but you work so many hours per week you never have the time to enjoy the money.
I wish I could walk on water.
Granted, but you become an easy meal for some sharks.
I wish I could change my hair color at will without having to dye it.
Granted, you still have to wait for it to grow out. (Bogus scene from Lucy)
I wish I could dream...
Granted, you have wonderful dreams at night but you never remember them when you wake up. (If you think you don't dream that's actually probably what's happening.)
I wish my cats could speak English.