The old one.

The new one.

I like the old one more, because on my opinion the new one is too sturdy and the head is too wide. It's too similar with the archan now. Actually I like all old versions from the tigrean more because of the same reason.

Edit: If the proportions from the NEW tigrean will apply to the archan I would support this. By an archan the proportions from the current tigrean would looks alike more natural than how the archan is now at this moment.

Tiger Lion

Revamp is much better.

God, the old tigrean was bad. I never understood why people loved the old tigrean, because it looked like a Lion King reject.

tigrean revamp was 2nd best revamp to me

Tigrean = tiger, which are by far stockier than the average lion (which is the archan).

inb4 'fantasy creatures not real ones' most of subeta's pets are based off real animals, so it's not out of place for them to have the same or similar proportions and anatomy.

I like the revamp. It's much more detailed, and nicely updated. 'Lion king reject' is fairly apt for the old art.

It might be only me but the back paws and legs seem very small even if they are seen in perspective. Especially with how huge the front ones are. Might be just me though.

Hey, if you still like the old, jelly-for-arms, broken spine, neckless Galactic Tigrean, good for you.

I personally prefer the revamp of this, because the old one was way too dark with my stupid monitor, and I never cared for its personality. Here, the new one looks more regal, and the foreshortening is really the only way to fit such a large tiger in such a tiny canvas limitation.

I do wish there were a few gold markings extended down to the belly more,as that's my favorite aspect of the Tigrean, but overall, this is a beautiful revamp.

also, not understanding why OP feels the need to draw a comparison between the Archan and Tigrean, when both are clearly based on two distinctly separate species of big cats, lion and tiger respectively. That's like comparing apples to pears. Just because they share similar cat-like aspects does not mean they're equally similar anatomically, which allows each to function respectably in their native habitats.

Not feeling this revamp at all. I feel like this is a pet that needed a revamp, and the artist was on the right track, but the final result falls flat.

What's going on with the eyes?

It looks more 'accurate' to a tiger I suppose. But now it looks like it's trying to be limber and graceful and it's too stiff to do so.

The galactic tigrean is a huge source of nostalgia for me, because it was my first pet and I had it for about 5 years before I finally changed it. It's always been my favorite galactic pet. Unlike OP, I've actually really loved all the tigrean revamps, and I was really looking forward to this one.

It might be the nostalgia talking but now that the revamp is here, something about it feels off. I love most of it though (especially the new paws and the extra detail on the markings).

After staring at it for a while, I think it's mainly the face/head that bother me. I think the inner part of the left eye (our right) makes it look like it's open too wide, or like it droops down on the face a little. I also feel like the head is back too far, but that might be personal preference.

Original -- Tweak -- Tweak

I'll have to come back to this after I get more used to the revamp, and see if I still feel the same way.

[edit]

I made another minor edit to adjust the angle on the right eye (our left), because someone mentioned that the perspective seemed off and I think I agree. You might need to open the images in different tabs and flip between them to actually see what I changed, but I think it makes a big difference.

I'm always for more details and shadings in a revamp too, but I like to "nag" about the anatomy. :P

Inside these two pictures you show, the eye by your tweak seems indeed better omo.

I do like your tweaked version much better. the eye does look off.

the original one looks so floppy, I kinda like it for some reason.

I was staring at this for so long trying to see the difference because when you said "right eye" I instinctively went for what would be the animal's right eye, not the eye on the right side of the picture.

Now that I see it yours does look a bit better.

The eye is only thing that bothers me. I would have never realized that was it if I hadn't seen your edit, . I'd like to see it edited but it's a little less bothersome to be able to pin-point and not just get this general feeling of something being off.

It's like the difference between a beanie-style stuffed kitty and a real cat. The real ones are significantly more likely to launch random "I-have-decided-I-don't-want-your-attention-because-you-want-to-give-it" scratch attacks but they are better for snuggling when they are in a snuggle mood... Because they are basically little purring heaters. However, the floppy stuffed versions are nice too and significantly less dangerous to life (well, more accurately, treasured possessions collected during life) and limb (literally this though). XD

Overall like it. Agree on the eye bit, but still like it a lot.

I love the common tigrean revamp, its actually one of my favourite pets, but this doesnt have the sleek, fierceness of the common tigrean and i feel there is definitely something wrong with its face. It almost seems a bit too big and chubby and i think its forehead seems strange, like it overhangs a bit too far if that makes sense. Am not feeling this revamp at all.

Overall I like the revamp a lot, definitely a big improvement. But like others have said, the eye placement and shape could use a little bit of tweaking. And it seems to have a slight underbite, with the lower jaw jutting out and to the left (of the image) a bit too much.

I really love the new markings! So gorgeous and intricate! :D And for some reason, I like the back legs... I cannot explain it though. They just look cute? I agree with something being off about the head, but cannot pinpoint it. Maybe something about the jaw? Just... seems like it is open oddly compared to the rest of the head. 's edit is wonderful though! Subtle, but it definitely helps.

Something about the pose just seems very...non-dynamic? The movement of the front body does not seem to match the lower body. But the line work and details are an improvement.

- While I was playing around in photoshop, I noticed that the colors on the revamp seem desaturated, and resaving the image fixed it somehow. I remember this happening with the steamwork tigrean. Is this something you could look into?

- No, the steamwork tigrean was fixed ages ago, fortunately.

The difference on the galactic tigrean isn't nearly as extreme, but I think it's still off a little. I can see it clearly when I open this and this in different tabs and flip between them. I didn't adjust the colors at all in my edit, but somehow it came out more vivid.