Replies

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
METROID
has been EXTERMINATED
User Avatar
Havoc

two ONE issue I have with the system.

  1. What harm is there in letting blocked users view the blocker's profile?

Suppose the blocker ends up leaving their account inactive or they get iced. Said blocker has a pet name you really want, but you can't find out the date the account will be cleared or free, because the "lol BLOCKED" error greets you.

sol: Still block any means of communication, but allow blocked users to still view blocker's profile.

2. Another problem, say someone changes their UN to that blocker's account. I'm still blocked by the username. sol: Instead, shouldn't I be blocked by the UserID #--cause that doesn't ever change?

Thank you for clarifying. My mistake. :)

I may be alone in this, but I would like to see changes to this. Feel free to agree/disagree.

[flower=Metroid]

Wanna know more about battling? ❤️ The Official Battle Guide v3.3 ❤️ Need to find books? 🌈 The Book Grind Guide v1.0 🌈

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
Keith
is sweet
User Avatar
Eradication

Blocking is by userid, not by username.

💖 ✨ 🤗

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
METROID
has been EXTERMINATED
User Avatar
Havoc

Thank you for that clarification. Had a feeling it was, but wasn't sure.

[flower=Metroid]

Wanna know more about battling? ❤️ The Official Battle Guide v3.3 ❤️ Need to find books? 🌈 The Book Grind Guide v1.0 🌈

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
Aztec
is a bad omen
User Avatar

To be honest I do think it's a little strange that we're blocked from viewing the profile. It's not like we can contact them, I'm not sure why we can't just look at their page.

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
Courtesy
is the pumpkin king!
User Avatar
Jane

I fail to see the issue with how it is, to be honest. The gripe about it interfering with stalking an account clearing is minor and a pretty unlikely situation to find oneself in. The point of blocking is to sever all contact between the individuals as if they don't exist, so it falls in line with the idea to hide their activities from those they've blocked.

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
poppet
User Avatar

I apologize if this isn't the case here, but this seems like a personal user issue veiled as a general site suggestion. -_-

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
METROID
has been EXTERMINATED
User Avatar
Havoc

That definitely isn't the case here. I haven't been blocked by anyone in a super long time. Rather, this just randomly surfaced to my thoughts while looking over my friends list today.

[flower=Metroid]

Wanna know more about battling? ❤️ The Official Battle Guide v3.3 ❤️ Need to find books? 🌈 The Book Grind Guide v1.0 🌈

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
poppet
User Avatar

Sorry for thinking that then! ^_^;

For people stalking usernames or pet names, I'm pretty sure they can already always just view user profiles when logged out of Subeta.

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
METROID
has been EXTERMINATED
User Avatar
Havoc

Apology accepted. =) I think you're right about being logged out and viewing profiles. Lemme check that out.

Cause though it'd be a bit of a hassle at times, it does get around the problem.

[flower=Metroid]

Wanna know more about battling? ❤️ The Official Battle Guide v3.3 ❤️ Need to find books? 🌈 The Book Grind Guide v1.0 🌈

Dec 26, 2013 12 years ago
Thundercracker
made a living
User Avatar
Serrated

I don't want people who blocked me to see my profile. if they don't like me that much well :P they can stay away from stalking me and my pets.
Same with people who I blocked. I don't want to see their profiles because I don't want anything to do with them. If they went inactive then I'd unblock them. otherwise it seems rather harassing if you check on their profile and are able to. just my two cents.

Holiday Clickables | |

Dec 27, 2013 12 years ago
InSaNe
is all-powerful
User Avatar
Hydragellos

you can still see if a pet name is available for purging even if it's owned by someone that has blocked you

just my two cents, or as we say here in zimbabwe, 2 million dollars

Your signature is 913 px wide by 77 px tall. Please note this can be affected by CustomCSS if you have any.

(Because text affects the width of your signature, we suggest testing with all text removed to be sure your width is correct.)

Dec 27, 2013 12 years ago
Major
Blanche
User Avatar

Eh. I dont particularly think its a big issue when you can just check most things in another browser / while logged off -shrugs-

However, I find it kind of strange that blocked people can't join any groups created by the blocker. Or rather, I do view a purpose behind that, but it can become really inconvenient for big / important ping groups that can affect someone's site experience as a whole and thus should be beyond the reach of the function imo :/

This forumset art was made by ! ^_^

Dec 28, 2013 12 years ago
Jack
thinks every day is taco tuesday
User Avatar
Aether

Not sure how it's "harassing" to just look at someone's profile? I mean, if there was an off-site issue of User A looking at User B's profile just to use information there to bitch about User B elsewhere... I guess that's an issue, although one that could be solved off-site and doesn't really have anything to do with Subeta itself. I dunno, I just don't see why you'd feel so violated by someone just looking at your profile?

I don't have a strong opinion for or against the suggestion. I don't have a problem with blocked users seeing my profile, but I don't think it's a very important issue to consider "fixing".

I will love you forever if you trade me:

Dec 28, 2013 12 years ago
Historiography
is a Time Lord
User Avatar
Nein

It's not necessarily harassing, persay, but I can see what Knockout is saying when they mean they don't want anything to do with another user who has blocked them, even insomuch as allowing a blocked person to view what is theirs, so to speak. It's essentially an out of sight, out of mind type thing.

Plus, as others, InSane, for instance have stated, you can still search for a pet, you just can't view that particular person's profile if you have them blocked.

As such, I think the system is fine as is.

Dec 28, 2013 12 years ago
Tribunal
has a bad feeling about this
User Avatar

Since there is (and should be, don't get me wrong) no criteria for blocking someone, it should affect the blocked person as little as possible. Not being able to see their profile affects you, even if very minorly.

You should still be able to see the profile. Move the "You've been blocked!" page to if you click 'leave comment' or 'smail'. Or just have it as a popup/hover on their profile.

Want to keep up to date with important news about Subeta that may not be obviously posted on site? Consider joining the "News" forum group today! Check out my StyleFile?

Jan 10, 2014 12 years ago
Guardian29
the escape artist
User Avatar

hmmm not sure i see a problem either way but i havent had to deal with it.

Please log in to reply to this topic.