'have to', wow you should be happy to eat pudding

Depends on the flavour

Define "pudding".

I feel like we may be putting too much thought into it, but I dunno. :c

the sweet kind, not savory

That I don't have to drive to a gourmet store and hunt down a can of spotted dick is a relief, I guess.

Yeah I am getting nowhere and fast with this....

So... the solution actually does involve pudding? No one’s joking about that?

I tried feeding my pet various puddings (including blood pudding, ew). That didn’t work.

Really the only things I can think of that would make an music lover angry are destroying instruments or other musical equipment, or telling them that their taste in music sucks or something.

We can't really feasibly do the second thing on Subeta, so that leaves the first option. I think we've probably tried deleting almost everything in the shop by this point, between everyone, unless we have to delete multiple things across a range of items. I'm just not sure enough about it though, or what items to keep trying it with.

No, the pudding was a joke :P

Im obsessed with the thought of hot pretzels, Ive got 43 in my inventory lol, but nothing when I went to his shop.

It said he likes pretzels though, which is why I don't think that's it. Unless it's having messy pretzels and instruments in your inventory at the same time and getting crumbs and cheese and stuff all over the instruments.

I don't really think that would be it, but you're welcome to try.

I tried giving him a Poop Chocolate Coated Pretzel Stick for good measure and that did not work :P

i deleted one of each violin he stocks (and then a bunch of the minions he stocks) and got nuffin. if it's something absurd like delete one of everything he stocks then... lmao that's gonna have to wait, i already have too many tabs open. also i have tacos to eat. but mostly i have too many tabs open and my browser is protesting p;

Yeah, I've gotta eat dinner and then get some other stuff done as well. I might try some more later tonight in between doing quests, unless someone else has already figured it out by then.

Good luck guys!

I've tried fragging and combining instruments at the Lab. I don't think those are it either.

[edit]You've found a Hidden Opponent! Johannes challenges you to a fight in the Battle Coliseum!

SCORE.

HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIINT! Please....

GOod job, congrats!