fingers crossed! i'm hoping his fear will be related, at least o:

guessing is more fun, for me at least! i like surprises, haha

i think it's totally random x;

I am not good at this kind of thing but maybe see spoiler I am not a fighter but need that plush where do I get help on what weapons to use please Yes as a matter of fact I did ... it totally happened by accident

huh... bought one but that didn't trigger anything either, o: thanks for letting me know, though!

Will let you know but he's still not challenging me.... Man he's such a butt... xD

Here is what I did maybe that is what triggered it.

its probably something on your HA then

just fyi nothing to do with free beer

Still getting nowhere.

You're a free beer!

I am not a battler and I was looking around at weapons and came across this that I had for sale in one of my shops so I removed it and it was in my inventory also.

three things thats all that's in my inventory now.

I tried the bludgeon right now. Nothing don't worry about it.

[edit] tried MCAB too

My inventory was Free Beer, MCAB, and bludgeon

I bet it has more to do with her HA. anyway you could list out your HA?

Oh good, thank god for that too.

The only worthwhile thing I've seen on her HA is the Misery Lotus, the seafoam item, and Ghouls thing. But compared to Froggy's, there's no correlation with whatever is on a person's HA.

Its probably not going to be any item in particular, its probably something like wear an item with the word green in it or use a certain type of eyes. They probably don't have anything that overlaps directly. (I already tried to be a zombie when I went there.)

I've tried visiting him with a dead pet, unhappy, and hungry pet. Although if it were the last two a lot more people would be saying that unlocked him.

My friend was wearing this when she got it from visiting Gunther.

Private Outfit

Well, when someone figures out what the prerequisite is, mail me. Too frustrated to keep trying to solve it. I hate when we have to mess around in the wardrobe or alter our HA just to unlock an opponent.