I liked it better without wishlist peek, it allowed me to find items I didn't knew existed, and I had less duplicated.

A triplicate today, a duplicate as well. It's not as much, not as wild.

I like the idea of the wishlist, but maybe it needs to be refreshed every single time

Today I received triple of two items. So three of one and three of another. It's not a huge deal, but it's definitely not something that I suspect was intended with the WL being open.

I have to imagine the duplicate items are from Melody buying them and not the wishlist peek, since both times she's bought items from my shop she's bought out all two or three I had in stock at the same time. I can't imagine a world where Melody and all three other participants bought and contributed the same two candies resulting in me getting 4 of one, 3 of the other and the 4th sitting in the pool lol-

SPOILER (click to toggle)

The first few days were in some ways more fun because there was more mystery in chucking items in, but I have in ways enjoyed the wishlist peek as it has shown me items I didn't know existed and hope got back to the people who wished for them. This wild west of receiving a seemingly infinite amount of dupes sure is interesting- Anyway if anyone needs some Blood and beetle cake balls let me know

I loved the mystery items from yesterday! I do wish the wishlist would refresh.

I have to admit that I also preferred the experience before the wishlist peek. I got 4 of the same 80k sp item! I have enjoyed doing this so that I can put some more expensive items back into circulation, but the wishlist peek seems to have throttled it down to just... the same few less-than-150k items across the board, unfortunately. I was having a lot of fun up until this point, though! Thanks to the team for all of the (continued) effort to get this running for us <3

So, these are the items I received from yesterday's pool. All are WL items which is great. But again...the duplicates and triplicates make it a little less fun overall.

SPOILER (click to toggle)

I've been buying one item from everyone's WL and then throwing 1-2 higher end value items into the pool. At this point I'm not sure whether it's Melody duplicating and triplicating the items or the users but...do you think y'all can look into this, please?

I got a ton of duplicates yesterday. 3 of one item, 2 of another. Also, I feel like the way to add items to the pool has taken a HUGE step back!!! I go to page 2 to add items and after checkmarking said item, it jumps back to page 1. Going back to page 2 I get a 404 error, then I have to refresh the entire thing. I wish it would go back to how we were able to add things, it was simple, worked and far superior than what is going on now. It can take me up to 5 minutes just to get the 5 items added into the pool.

2 things-

1. Somehow I was able to add 6 items today. I took the extra out when I noticed. I'd added 2 items first, refreshed once I bought the other 3, and I guess I clicked another thing without realizing it before hitting add

2. I wish there was a lower threshhold for items. There's been days where most of my items are under 10k. Whether that's coming from the other players or Melody, IDK, but I really hope for next year we can group into targeted price ranges each day. (Under 100k, 100k-500k, 500k-1m, 1M-10m, 10M+)

So today I can't even add items- when I click on them, it brings me to a listing of whatever item I clicked on.

this was probably the most disappointing day when it came to distribution of items. I got 7 items, 6 of which were dupes, expensive dupes, 3 Risky Kittys, but still the distribution was out of sorts.

I think the update before the Wishlist peak was the one that worked the best.

Today I'd "just unlocked four new reactions", rofl. It seems, not evereybody gets that on a daily basis?

I am super happy with my MM surprise parcel: Got 7 presents, 6 of them WL! 2 of the same book I had gotten once earlier (weird coincidence), still need a couple of, 4 boosters (3 identical), all I'd gotten before as well, but those we need to infinity. Single non WL was a Subi Invite, fortunately only 1 out of the 4 in the group.

Group repeats not too many, since I luckily ;-) got the majority: Altogether 4 Subi Invites, same Minion twice, wearable yet different colour 2 times twice.

As far as I recall almost everything were WL items of my partners. I did not contribute a single WL item.

There is something going not to plan with the WL peek. How come, there are so many of the very same item and for each person also repetitive on days?

P.S. My joy of this MM has been utterly ruined by today's Melody gift. I've had the most relaxed holiday, because obviously Melody wasn't giving out new books this year and now the stress starts again sob

PPS: I'd prefer, that the MM info stayed closed after closing it, not reopening itself upon every refresh. Being a huge banner above the acivity fields is annoying. There is enough scrolling to do without the game info, which understandably needs to remain on top for newbies.

I really do not like the WL peek feature. So far it has led to loads of duplicates in the groups I was in. And not of things like various site currencies, but the items from the WL peek.

Today I got 7 items, 2 of them from my WL. The item pool had 3 minions from my WL in it. One of it twice, the others three times even. I got neither of them, but got 4 items that were shown from others wishlists. I don't want to complain about the items I got. It just feels off getting nonWL items that would have been nice for someone else and vice versa.

The amount of duplicates bothers me most. Not that one day before the WL peek where apparently everyone in my group decided that Subeautique invites, tokens and stat boosters were the best gifts. But the up to 3-4 identical WL peek items? Meh. I would much prefer if each user got a different random WL peek from the others. That way we could each pick (a) WL item(s) for everyone if we wanted without loads of duplicates (unless several people want the same item, but that's fine). Or back to none at all, because the mystery gifts everyone put in were mostly really nice.

okay once again happy with the items I got it's fine since there are always things from my WL - but I think I also get a lot of stuff I have no intereste in (I can still sell it)

I do not think I like the WL peek - I have just participated 4 times but it looks as though there is not much of aroatation so what ever is shown in the morning ends up with way to manny copies.

I have waited 8 hours and refreshed a few times - but so far I still have not seen a full shift.

I love this - I just hope next year we can get a more changing WL peek

Next group is full. Melody has finished adding her 8 items - all food, so nothing from my WL, while no one of the 4 of us has contributed anything yet. Also I only see 2 members' WL. Which has happened before...

What happens, if nobody else in the group adds items? Do I get mine back and 5 from Melody?

Do you get less items if you add yours later than the others? I contributed five items, as did everyone else (+ Melody's eighth), and received 4 items this morning

It finally happened, I received a gift I bought from someone else's wishlist back :( Also I'm convinced melody is buying multiple of the same minions and things rather than the others but who knows lol

I received the same two items multiple times. I understand its on my wishlist but it is disappointing to see the same item numerous times. Especially when it's a wearable going to the wardrobe just once.

was received 4 times and three times. Maybe add in a feature that once a wishlist item is submitted by one person it greys it out for the others? It's anonymous anyways and you don't see your own wishlist items on there.

Otherwise, I have enjoyed this feature! I missed the old one and this is a fun alternative!

Melody really needs some adjustments. She is consistently overpaying for items. Yesterday she bought all 3 I had in a shop for 100k each when the lowest price for them is under 10k. That's just one example, but she keeps popping up in my sales history doing this. And she always buys multiples if I have them, so I also think she is the one adding the same item to the MM pools.

Last night I got 7 items, 3 of the same minion, 3 of the same wearable, and one other minion.

The night before there were 4 of the same plushie, and 3 of the same beanbag in the pool. I didn't put any of them in, and I doubt the user that had them on their wishlist put any of them in. So I assume Melody was responsible for the multiples.

I haven't been a fan of the wishlist peeks.

It seems that all of my gifts this time came from a wishlist category I specifically have hidden because it's a reminder for myself to buy later, not things I would want to receive as gifts. That was really disappointing. :(

ETA: This also means I got 3 copies of the same book worth only 60k and the rest of my presents were also worth about the same. I saved up some donation presents and boosters as an extra big gift for yesterday, which I guess is not something I'd consider doing again.

so today is the first day I am not to happy about what i got. Snow faieries? More then one? Is ther a way we could be able to "block" certain items? I totally understand not gettin WL items - I love what I sometimes get, since books I can always read to any other pet boosters are always helpful I even like the flowers but Fairies?

Still excited - so far I only had groups where everyone participated. Again I will add my WL items later today I am hoping to avoid doing doubles

I also try to guesss what is in already - seeing WLs peeks and such