ugg, i guess riight but, i didnt get to shoe inspector thorpe the bookend... ugg i hope i still pass
Gotta say that even though I had figured it was Marcel, this chapter managed to actually sicken me. I can't believe how hideous Marcel really is and poor Vic for having an uncle like that! Now she's got to live knowing all that 
Awwww... I guess wrong... pets Garrett Sorry about that.
Thanks Subeta.
I thought it was him, too.
haha! I got it right! Awesome plot. 
i guessed my answer hahaha
Sweet! I guessed right.
W00t! I was right. 8D
Dang.
Ha! I knew it! I knew that he would betray his friend for his greed considering the other character looked to obvious and innocent...case solved!
greatest plot ever!!!
so Marcel did it?! dang....i thought he didn't...
I was going to guess Marcel as well, but...when I went to do that, was told I couldn't talk to Thorpe anymore
I am kicking myself for not even guessing, despite my hunch that it was Marcel. :/
Bah, I guessed wrong. X_X Guess I should have paid more attention to the notes and such.
I just hope that prizes or whatever are not based on who you accused as there was not really 100% proof that it was Marcel, anyway am disappointed it was him, but still was fun!
yess I was right :3
I had a feeling but. Completely forgot the time limit on making an accusation. Oh well. x]
Wohoo, guessed correctly. XD
I loved this plot guys. It was/is awesome!
Awesome, got it right
Fun plot! <3'd it.
OMG. 
Dang, I knew it was Marcel but I wasn't home to put my guess in. Oh well, the event was still fun, thanks Subeta! 
So intelligent, Subeta. By making someone starkly obivious and even pointing right at the enemy, you convince people to think "too obvious, must look for alternative!".
But I didn't fall for it. Now... prize?
This was a lot of fun even though I didn't get all the items from the study.
LAYTON'S APPRENTICE SAAAVES THE DAAAAAY
Except not really yet whatever. God Luke step on it.
YUSSS! I WAS RIGHT.
Noooooo......I thought Adriette did it
sorry Adriette.....
thanks subeta...
very nice. I just adore this whole plot!
I really liked the plot. I'm just bummed I didn't finish it by midnight. :p
Just saying, that I am unhappy that I missed it, not pissed at the staff and all. Sorry about that.
Ugh, there should of been more time to guess! I have been on every single day since this started, and suddenly you opened that up and I was gone for the day- now I've missed it. TOTALLY not happy.
Haha yes!!
OMG I KNEW IT! Well actually I didn't. xD
I knew it! i was going between him and adriette, yay!
Well, bugger. 
Oooh I just guessed Marcel! Lucky me.
HAHAHA I GUESSED RIGHT. The one who's story makes the least sense is the most suspicious :p And to me, Marcel just seemed....suspicious.
Haha! I knew it.
O__O I KNEW IT, I KNEW IT! DAMN YOU!
Yes! I got it right!
I knew it was him yet i accused someone else! dammit
I knew it! ... but unfortunatly I just missed the midnight deadline cries oh well I am just glad it wasnt Issac or Vic! 
Yay!! I got it right!! I would have been so upset if it was Jules!!
LOL, I thought he was too obvious too... so I couldn't decide and didn't get it done. I expected there to be some really bizarre twist where everyone guessed wrong, or something.
I'm so glad I guessed the right one.
I KNEW IT!!! I knew he was no good after he snatched my journal page away!
Well, shit.
I had made no guesses, so really wasn't too bugged by who it was. All I can say is that with friends like Marcel, no one needs enemies.
Yay! I guess right! 8D
ugg, i guess riight but, i didnt get to shoe inspector thorpe the bookend... ugg i hope i still pass