So this is just something weird I noticed recently (and probably should've noticed before!) Many of the items from Melody's Cottage don't match up with the year AT ALL. Like the item previews they show for the year don't always match up (Five Golden Rings, for instance, was given out in 2007, which isn't even an option for a year to pick). And then what you receive doesn't necessarily match up either. Today I picked 2010 and 2009 - then got one item from 2010 and one from 2006. I'm happy with my items, but wanted to let someone know that Melody's advertising is a little off!