Last year I could have sworn someone had a guide up to help people attempting to make what they needed at the Alchemist. Obviously, that thread was lost when the holiday ended and the forums closed. That person seems not to have posted this year, and I am stuck trying to guess color/token/layer combos. Is there one that I’m missing somewhere? I have no clue where to look.

There's https://subeta.net/forums.php/read/10274 thread, it has the info for older items, it has been closed tho for being quite old. I don't know it there is a newer one. Alternatively, you can look up items you need on Subetalodge, it has instructions how to make it in item notes.

Thank you both very much!