I am trying to complete the Shark Bait achievement so I can get the Shy Shark. I have purchased all of the required items except the Blue Tang which I cannot find anywhere. Any suggestions?? Thanks.

The Blue Tang is also a fishing prize. However, looks like it wasn't a particularly common one. Seems they've all been bought up. Sorry.

Everyone wants things right away. But as far as I know there's no time limit on getting this achievement, so no worries. Maybe add it to your wish list, and just keep checking from time to time.

EDIT: flail Just remembered that borrowing items for achievements is also a thing! There's a thread around somewhere on the Achievement forums just for that. I don't know if that'll work in this case, I'm not trying for the achievement myself, but maybe worth a shot?

Not sure borrowing would work in this case, since the achievement is for feeding the poor fishies to your pet. 😂

you may have to try fishing up your own for now! Or wait until people are selling them again after they've fished them up.

That's what I get for not actually checking the achievement requirements, lol

Thanks for the clarification

thanks guys. I'll just keep fishing, and checking the shops & trades.

The Shyshark is caught through Fishing. The Shyshark Bait is what you get from completing the achievement. According to the news, the bait doesn't actually help you catch the Shyshark. You may already know this, but your opening post was a little unclear about which one you were trying to get.

I didn't actually notice that the bait doesn't help catch the shy shark. Thanks.