Before 2010, are they still random or did that change?

tbh I cant recall, but I want to say they changed em all to the select the item you want, let me see if I need something from tis month before that yr and Ill let ya know

edited to add: at least 2010. 2009 and 2008 seem to be choose the item

thank you so much for the info!

welcome, I happened to still need some plushies from some of em so checked em out