Hey everyone, I'm trying to make a nostalgic Scootle . I have all the items (the toy + magic essence) and space for an extra pet. But when i click on the toy it takes me to a page saying "That is not your pet". Not really sure why this is happening. Any help would be awesome.

You can't create a new pet at Vanya's. He turns your active pet into a nostalgic pet.

Make the pet that you want to become the Nostalgic Scootle, make sure it's your active pet, then go back to Vanya.

Thank you for the info! :D