Is there any way to change the tier of the subscription without first canceling? I can't seem to find an option to do so. The cancel confirmation pop up does seem to imply you can make changes to a subscription, though that could be referencing payment method.

to my knowledge, no..which is silly imo

nope. it's a feature that was intended to be added but has been on the backburner.

Thanks both. I canceled (it would have renewed today) and I will re-subscribe :)