I recently started playing so this might already be a thing and I didn't notice but! I think it would be fun if different pet species had different reactions to foods, toys, etc. For example, some species could be polite and quietly eat, others eat it whole. Maybe a pet could roast their food before eating it.
I say this because the default dialog felt very jokey ("I can't eat any more... Just kidding!") and insulted the food at times which felt incharacter for my first pet, a Charlie. It was charming and kind of funny... But then my next pet said the same things so I realized it was just the default text.
It could give species personalities and be fun to read.
okay wait, i am very into this
[flower=Emily]
Honestly, this is super cute. I kind of really like this idea!

I was just telling my boyfriend yesterday that the pet I made into a character based off of him didn’t like chocolate milkshakes. And then I was like “Wait, is it an individual pet thing or a species thing?” and I gave one to my other Tigrean, who said it was “Okay”. Which was a fun little experiment, but made me think about something like this. So it’s funny a suggestion for it comes up!
Support! I love this idea (:
I think the reactions are just random, but I also do think this is a really adorable idea that could be fun to implement.
Even something like adding some new reactions to the pool would be a nice easy way to switch it up a bit and make the reactions less stale.
BUT adding some different random preferences to pets would be fun, but I would expect it would take a lot of work, since the preferences would have to be added AND foods will have to be tagged in some way so that the system can recognize the foods and give the appropriate reaction.
Some ideas for "preferences" if this does move forward
Sweet tooth - Loves sweets but will complain about vegetables Snob - Loves foods over rarity 90, complains about low rarity foods Health Nut - Loves fruits/veggies, complains about greasy food
etc
This is a really cute idea!
LOL I would love to see my pet Chicklets, complain about eating eggy items (I know that would impractical due to the necessary food tagging, but fun to imagine)!
But a simple version where every once in a while a pet species would have a snarky, sweet or otherwise personality appropriate comment would be fun. Or maybe base it on color instead, or both.
In loving memory of Need posting achievements?Then join Posting Frenzy Achievement Items - searchable list List of Borders and cutouts New at Fresh and Flavorful Ping Group
omg I love this idea!!
Here is maybe an example of something that could be fun: If you try to feed a bovyne a Bovyne Steak, you could get a text like "Ugh! How could you?!" and your bovyne's happiness level would go down to 0/10.
etc for similar situations with other species
I also love this idea!
I would honestly love to do something this specialized and fun, but as someone pointed out it'd be a lot of work. I think going forward on the new site it'd be nice to keep something like this in mind as we build out new features. How the feeding system currently is, I don't think it's really feasible though. :(