I mean he already asks for MC items, like Sea Witch Talisman, so...why not screw us all the way?

That talisman is buyable, even if you'd rather not buy it to complete the quest - I know I wouldn't.

"Buy something that cost real money to get arbitrary sP amount" is not my idea of fun, not even counting the general hassle of buying and selling limited CWs anyway.

Well, I came here ready to rationally explain why this is a bad idea, and then I saw..

..nevermind.

Edit: - y'all might want to close this before it gets too ugly.

honestly an item hunt: hard mode which has the potential to ask for CWs would be so goddamn funny.

obviously not a good idea but it'd be SO funny

Would be funnier if this was posted 23 days ago.