I've been donating all sorts of pumpkins to Fantine, even harvesting Ghost Hunter Blake for more, but all I keep getting is food when what I really want is:

[item2=Pumpkin Pie Recipes]

Is this still possible? Or am I hoping for nothing?

I have a ton of these stashed away already, much higher than I would have gotten from just the pumpkins I donated this year. To me, which means they got given out from battling some Challenger. My guess is that items from 2015 are not on offer this year.

[edit] I just went through my storage shop where I temporarily shove everything from holiday events until it's over and there are no 2015 or earlier Fantine-pumpkin items. They're all 2016-2020.

Thanks for checking.

Subetalodge only says it was from Fantine. Do you know what challenger might also give it out?

It looks like I'm wrong on this one. I just went through the loots post made by the awesome on page 140 of Battle Chat and there are a few items that look like the one you want, none of them are the one you want.

Ah, okay. Thanks again.

Looks like I'll have to get them the monetary way.