I recently realized that I never unlocked Carl, but doing quests with "water" items in my inventory didn't unlock him. Is it too late?

There are a few stipulations: they have to be food items and rarity 1-99. I sent some items over, try it now?

Ahh, thank you! I'll try it tomorrow (I've finished all my quests for today).

I’m glad it worked! Congrats :D