I noticed this the other day while I was questing and wondered if it was just a one-off, but then I just had the same issue. Items that I have for sale in my shop (that are priced), are not always showing up in the shop search. It seems to be inconsistent and I have caught it a few times where I knew I had the item, but it was not showing up for me at the top when I did shop search.

More info: I was doing Quentin's quests today and I was asked for a . When I did the shop search, it gave me several user shops to buy from, and I went and purchased the item. Of course after I did so, I recalled that I had gotten that item while trick or treating the day beforehand. I wondered if I had already sold this item in my shop or if I still had it in there, after recalling the issue a few days ago where my shop's items were not always showing up in shop search. I did an item search and sure enough, I had it in my one shop and when I went to check, it was priced.

See images below-

SPOILER (click to toggle)

I am on Windows 10 and using Chrome Version 86.0.4240.75. I did also test this on Safari on my iPhone and had the same issue.

I just tried going through some random items in my shop and doing shop search, knowing that I do have them priced and available in a shop. While most random items I tested with are showing up at the top of the shop search results, I did find a few items that did not, like- , , , ...

I just randomly picked like 30 or so items to test this with and those are a few I found. I did not go through all my shop items. This is happening when I click to do the shop search option via the quests, the item hovers, and also typing the item into the shop search.

Thanks in advance for your help!

interesting. I guess I was under the impression that if I had the item in my shop that it would show up on the top of the list for me to remove regardless of the pricing. Thanks for letting me know!