I didn't realize until recently that some of the achievements were missing some of the newer colors. For example, the Cadogre is missing the Cherry color for the achievement. I never realized I was missing that one because it wasn't coming up for the achievement.

I don't like this idea. Maybe new Achievement could be created down the road to collect the new colors.

Shouldn't most of these Achievements be missing some colors? It's a massive undertaking and each one takes awhile to draw. It appears that these Achievements are meant to be the same size in terms of how many items you need. If one was created before the color existed, then it won't have that color. This is a way to deal with a moving target: Subeta continues to add colors.

iirc the cherry & silver colour lifelike dolls came after the first achievements were released, so all the lifelike doll achievements don't include the colours to keep the achievement requirements identical. Same thing will apply to the eventual aqua & vibrant lifelike dolls.

I wouldn't mind having a separate achievement for the colours that were excluded, but I'm not bothered by it either.

Moving the new colors to a follow up achievement works too. I am just pointing out that they were missing. I was under the impression that some of them did get added to the originals at a later date, since some had Nuclear included and others didn't.

Hm. This got me curious, so I went digging! Nuclear lifelike dolls were released when the lifelike dolls were first pushed as a feature. Link to the news post. Achievements for the lifelike dolls were pushed about 2 weeks later. Link to the first achievement post. Cherry & silver lifelike dolls were added nearly 6 months after the lifelike dolls were first released. Link to the cherry & silver lifelike doll news post.

Looking at itemIDs, some of the lifelike nuclear plushies (demi & montre) were definitely added later, so I'm guessing that's why they weren't included in the original achievements.

So yeah. I wouldn't mind having a separate achievement for the cherry & silver lifelike dolls, though they should probably separate those by species if they decide to do them. New lifelike dolls are still very slowly being added to the site and I don't think they can edit achievement requirements after an achievement has been added.

That makes absolute sense then! There's definitely some gaps still regarding colors & species on what hasn't been added. There's still no Spectrum, etc that could still be done to add bulk to a second grouping of achievements. All of this digging around has also revealed to me some other oddities, like Jollins having a Cherry lifesize doll, yet no plush or beanbag.