So I basically need TCs item for her. I've started by looking for potions but you'll get a better idea of what I need by reading her story (It's mostly complete by the way).

Maybe stuff related to sweethearts, IDK.

I just wanted to say I love your idea. If I think of anything I will post or edit my post. Actually I came across your thread when I was thinking about starting one to get advice for my little angel Crash. I am trying to feed him everything heart shaped with a few exceptions that just don't fit his tastes.

With Carasynthia's story I almost feel like you could use anything that might seem like an ingredient, but maybe an easy place to start would be bottles to put the potions in. Even though the items from Spells Galore are meant for magic I'm not sure many of them feel like they fit the love potion theme even with the addition of how they work. The herbs might be an exception or maybe items that are believed to be aphrodisiacs.

You could try creating a recipe for each of them ones mentioned and maybe some that weren't mentioned and then collect to items for those recipes in Carasynthia's TC. That way it would fit the story and help control the size of the TC while allowing you to control the cost of the TC a little.

- Maybe some of these will help: [item=Dr. Lockhearts Amorisporin-Medicated Bandages][item=Dr. Lockhearts Amoricone][item=Dr. Lockhearts Amoricide][item=Dr. Lockhearts Amortisone][item=Dr. Lockhearts Amoryl Cream][item=Dr. Lockhearts Hyperamory Inducer]

If you don't want only pink/heart items, I've got alchemy reagents here, and here!

Comes in multiple colors:

Other links alchemy ingredients crystal-y magic things potions (start about halfway down the page)