The battle challenger Pumpkin Patch Goblin should drop Gathered Goblin Eyes at 5 wins, but I defeated him 5 times with my main battle pet and did not receive this item. I received his other two drops, and . I asked people in the shout box if anyone else got the eyes, but several people confirmed they did not.

I'm wondering if this was intentional, and if so, why this item was cut from the loot drops. If it's a glitch, could I file a ticket to get the item?

I also had a similar issue during anniversary when the Spirited Shrine Coin did not give me the .

I'm sorry if this is in the wrong spot or a non-issue. I'm always worried about reporting issues

The ones to ask are the battle admins and I'll ping them for you.

Do note that the loot for reoccurring challengers can vary from year to year, and can sometimes include new items.

Yeah, they do usually rotate the special loot around from year to year, so not all of them are always given out every year.