I've fed [item2=Vegan Chocolate Chip Macadamia Nut Cookies] to Monokromatic, but

1 if I check the corresponding achievement, it doesn't register 2 account search shows nothing 3 Monokromatic is not listed if I hover over 'feed pets' (so I know he has eaten it)

how weird - right?

also - I have the cookie still in my inventory, somehow

If only chocolate chip macadamia nut cookies were infinite irl ...

did you actually get confirmation that your pet ate it in the first place? pets aren't supposed to show up on the list to feed if they're not hungry, but sometimes cache delays make them appear for a little bit anyway, only to reject the food because they are full. pets who have already eaten a food still appear on its list, they just have a note beside them stating that they've already eaten it. maybe wait until your pet's hunger is low and then try feeding them the cookie again.

the pet's hunger was low, I do recall him eating it - but I'll try it again, maybe there was something up at the time

(btw sorry for the super late reply!)

ETA: YAY! second time around worked!

and now I really want chocolate chip macadamia cookies... c:

this can be closed since all is well - thanks! :-)