I have noticed there are quite a few items from Subeautique that can also be eaten and I think it could be a neat achievement to have your pet eat them all. I am not very creative with names but I thought maybe it could have a title along with it like "Has Expensive Taste".

That would be actually nice. My pet has eaten quite some subq.

Um... I don't know...

I get that not every achievement should be easy, but having an achievement specifically for eating SBQ foods would really spike the prices and increase the demand for them.

If it was for eating any SBQ edibles from non-specific sets and it was capped at.. idk, 10, okay! I'm all for that, that would be fun! But if it's specific items, or an achievement to eat all current SBQ edibles, like OP is suggesting? Yikes...

I agree with 's suggestion of a small, tiered set of achievements that aren't set specific.

There are currently 30 edible Subeautique items, so I'd like to see something like 1, 5 and 15 as tiers.

The only other way I'd support something like this is with some way to get old retired Subeautique items onsite, like many people have already been asking for and have not yet gotten.

I think this could be a fun idea, but I also agree with the other two posters. This would be a very hard Achievement indeed. If it was implemented there'd be Suggestion after Suggestion after Suggestion on how to make it easier because "it's insane" or "it's just too hard". It also tends to favor those who have been playing here a long time and may have eaten these items back when they were both more easily available and relatively cheap. By the nature of Subeta, many Achievments already favors us old timer fuddy duddies quite a bit, even though we're not nearly as bad about Achievements here as Neopets is on their Secret Avatars where some of theirs are literally no-hope impossible.

I like the tier suggestion. That would make it a bit easier to get some of the achievements. I am a fairly new user (just celebrated my 3rd year) but I get my retired subq from the Gift of Fashions Past chance box and even Major Drills when he wants to be nice. Personally a lot of the retired subq is actually easier for me to obtain than most Blackheart Hollow and Token Shop items that are in the achievements but that is because I buy the chance boxes from the cash shop so I understand everyones points. Most people probably do not sink so much into those boxes as me, lol. Thank you all for posting :)

@/Victoria I totally get what you're talking about because I do the same thing. I don't think I managed to pull many edibles though. There are lots of retired SBQ items, lots of retired Vanity items, and the hair coupons. Oh and the repeats! Even people like us would probably still find collecting all of the edibles pretty difficult to do.

Some tiers might be fun though - that way we can take advantage of the ones that still restock.

I play drills a lot, and have a gotten a fair few Subtique items from him - but I've found his selection of prizes doesn't seem to include all the retired sets. Or maybe I just haven't been lucky.

As for gifts of fashion past, it costs CSC and that's just not something most people aren't going to be willing to buy very often.

I agree with , and I would like to add that there's already an achievement "Part of a Balanced Breakfast" with a Custom Trunk food item and at the beginning it was pretty impossible to get it until they changed how you can buy CT items but you still need to spend 65 CSC OR 10mil (lowest SS price)

So it would be a problem with retired food SBQ items, because the only way to get them is from the Gift Of Fashions Past chance machine = spending CSC.

Yeah I really would love to see the tier achievement. I understand the reluctance towards CSC items being achievements though. Maybe the final tier being somewhere around 10 or 15. I think that is pretty reasonable being the Eddie Bell Pizzazz line already has 7 items that are edible and it is not retired yet.