I'm making my first forays into CW making so, naturally, every single one of my items keep getting rejected with long lists of reasons. However, the lists being presented as alerts in the sidebar a) makes them hard to read or preserve for future reading/comparison with earlier rejections and b) makes them look really, really long which on first glance is very despiriting. Being presented with what looks like a massive paragraph of 'this is why your item sucks' makes the heart sink, until I copypaste and realise it's quite short. Could there be a way of collecting CW rejection messages that doesn't rely on off-site documents which could get lost, aren't available at all places, etc? I say this partly because I forgot to save the first message; I was too downcast by the sight of a 'wall of text' I deleted it.

This is a WONDERFUL idea. I completely support it.

When I get denials I feel obligated to leave them in my sidebar until I've got time to fix the item and this really stresses me out when it's a day off or I don't have time to get to it for a while. If there was a page, this would be so much easier, and it would be good for artists to be able to look back on and see their changes / improvements and what they've learned.

:)

Not a CW creator but support either way. Putting the entire rejection message in a sidebar event seems more than a little unwieldy. It is ridiculously easy to accidentily close a event especially when fat-fingering your way through the site on mobile.

It would be nice. As points out, it’s easy to fat finger away a rejection notice on mobile, so we might accidentally lose the fix list before we even have a chance to copy it into a text file. Heck, a little fat finger slip may cause us to lose it while copying it to a text file if we mistakenly hit the close icon while selecting.

Oof yeah. 😬 I'm not a CW maker, but that seems like it should definitely be a thing. Like said, events are super easy to delete on accident even if you're careful. And especially on mobile.

Full support!

we agreed it is a good and reasonable suggestion

Can I hug you right now? This is amazing