A few days ago I took out 3 pets from the resort to start working on achievements with them. I gave the pet I was walking a toy and they became happy. Tried to give it one the next day, max happiness. I figured it was due to me having them on the leash, so I gave the toy to the second pet in line, Selphee. I then tried the next day to give Selphee toys to play with, and got the same message of they are too exhausted to play anymore. I say okayyy....and give ONE toy to the next pet in line. I just logged on and tried to then give the 3rd pet a toy and they are giving me the same message of they are too happy etc. So I gave the toy to my last pet I took out and I'm pretty sure it's going to be the same story for that pet by tomorrow.

Do any of those pets have minions? Minions keep pets at max happiness when attached.

__< was this something that was newly added....? I took a break from subeta for a few years and just recently came back in October, so I am terribly behind on a lot or just don't remember things and starting to feel like an a** about all these little things I'm running into.

It's easy to forget such a small detail given you've taken a break! But it's been like that as long as I can remember.

It really is! Thank you for clarification I felt like I was going crazy. Just going to have to slowly brush up on my Subeta knowledge again 😶