Think it was last year Warlgthroth became a challenger and for some reason I do not have him. Is it possible to obtain him?

unlocks Warlgthroth

Thank you for letting me know, was costly, sigh!

No problem! Just an fyi in case you miss one again - challenger totems from previous years usually come back during the Black Friday sale in November. They don't go on sale, but at least you have the chance to buy them again at normal price.

You know I checked to see if I had that challenger and he was not listed in my statistics as someone I fought. Nor was he listed under the cash shop list. So I bought it and it would not open stating I already have him and yes I do. Unfortunately I have 2 now. Oh well, one for sale.

Oh no, I'm sorry to hear that :(