Connie Plushie Rarity: 125 Obtained from opening an EPICon 2013 Bag

Gemini Plushie Rarity: 110 Monthly Donation Present Item: Randomly obtained from opening a June 2008 Donation Present

McDuffle Coat Plushie Rarity: 110 Monthly Collection Item: Obtained from opening an April 2011 Collection

Year of the Pig Plushie Rarity: 160 Prize for Trivia (also, apparently a Crystal Shop item-not currently available)

I'm in the process of clearing out my hoard and any help would be appreciated

The donation presents are no longer random when opening so I would price the Gemini plushie around the price of the June 2008 Donation Present...looks like it is 34 mil. The same with the McDuffle, the April 2011 Collection is around 42.5 mil.

The other two have price histories on subetalodge (click on the "not enough data" part for each) but I am not sure ho accurate those are?

Ah, okay! That helps a lot :D I didn't know that about the presents and I have a few! Good to know it's not random :D And thanks for the tip on the "not enough data" part. Didn't notice that either. Now I have an idea on the prices at least <3