[edit]I need to slow down and read what's put before me, lol.

Ah, the fan achievement is for feeding them to your pet, not a wardrobe one.

... Ohshi-- really? Well, heck.

Yeah it was a bit confusing with the items with double functions.

I saw your edit though, did you just put the reapers in your wardrobe? Because I know it can take a few minutes to register if you viewed the achievement recently and then added items and viewed it again.

I clearly read it too fast, lol. How embarrassing.

There goes the reaper one, okay.