It'd be interesting to see a pirate pet color, especially if it were part of Keel Hauliday. There are already some plushies for pirate pets, which might at least take some pressure off the artists as far as designing the pets, and with all the pirate minions there are, it'd be great to have a pet that actually goes with them by default, in my opinion.

As for distribution, maybe it'd be best to have it be more quest-like, like with Hydrus and Galactic pets. The items in the shop already go so quickly, which would make it incredibly hard to grab something like a potion, and it'd be a more interesting addition. Maybe something like "pirate training" - either just as a normal quest, or something like Major Drills' quests, but with harder goals.

Still, since there's already thoughts about making a pirate item distribution, maybe a potion could be added to that as an alternative.

(Sorry if there are lore reasons that it isn't a good idea, I haven't played that much, so I'm not very familiar with all that.)

With the exception of nostalgic pets, I wouldn't except to see pets with clothing being colors. It could be done with overlays. People have suggested pirate, Oriental, and possibly others like Western but they didn't take off mainly because of this reason.

Although somewhat of a digression, I'd be interested to see another ocean color other than Hydrus. Maybe some deep sea theme unique enough to differentiate it from the latter.

It's kinda niche, tbh. Most other colours can be used for many different things - even Nostalgic - but a pirate is a pirate. I hate saying 'get an overlay' but this sounds like a job for an overlay.

Since the clothes is an issue and gives me personally some Neopets horrors, I would prefer to transform this color into the "Pirates Lore" like more into sea monsters, booty, skeletons, tropical mutated animals etc.

Like Mahar covered with gold coins instead of diamonds. Tribe-like Three headed Manchu The Chelon can be a mix between a turtle and a Kraken. And so on..

I would like to have a washed out color, with scars, pets who have seen lots of battles, a duller version of Common, but I don't think that I want it to be pirate-themed

Something obviously WAY less gory than Graveyard. Give me some badass action, without them being supernatural in nature or murderers.

A "good" counterpart to Bloodred, in a way.