@ Espresso

This item will turn your pet into a golden cadogre c:

The gold potion does not work because (apparently) Calvin Blackmoon won't allow it - The golden cadogre is a "special" species/color combination. I'm not entirely sure why the mystical toy works though. (Partially I'm just a bit new to the lore myself to be quite honest!)

I will check with other staff about this, and definitely at least look into changing the error message to be clearer about why this is.

Hello again! I did check up on this and it's something that's been around for a long time, so long that the original lore isn't even that relevant anymore. But the creative staff are aware and are figuring out how to address it (maybe by writing new lore? who knows?)

Thanks for bringing it up and being patient with us :) Hope this helps clear it up a little bit!

Going to lock this up since it's not actually a bug. :)