Thankfully the achievement for Making A Living is correctly counting how much sP my shop has made (346,363,935 sP) but the amount on Total Profits (98,180,870 sP) is wrong. This isn't anything major. I'm just confused why they don't match. I checked the known errors for shops and it lists the max for Total Profits as 2,147,483,647sP which I'm waaaaay below.

Are you talking about the sP in your till? Have you collected some before? Because if so, it's only going to show how much is in your till since the last time you collected, and that won't be the same as the total amount the shop has made since you created it.

I did have 250,000,000 sP in my shop till I recently withdrew (because I got the achievement) but my Total Profits did not update after that. My Total Profits is less than what I withdrew and I don't understand how I could withdraw more sP than what it says my shop has made.

Where are you seeing total profits though, are you looking at old shops?

Because I just see sP in Till, Lifetime Items Sold, and Lifetime sP Made on my shops page.

If you moved any profits over from your old shop to your new shop, it will count in the making a living but not the lifetime sP made for the new shop. Is it possible that this is why it is different?

Oooooh. I thought the profits from the old would just carry over to the new shop. That's what's up. I get it now. Thank you.

It did but only for the achievement :D glad it was that! Locking as this is not a bug.