Replies

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar

Hello, everyone.

So... I'm trying to comission another ponytail pigtail wig but I'm super unsure and I would like to hear some opinions.

First WIP Version:

Second WIP Version:

Here are the questions, to make this more objective:

  1. Which one do you like the most?

  2. Would you be interested in slotting on any of them in the future? (consider only the style here, ignore the color)

  3. What could I change to make it better?

Thank you for your help! ❤

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Pac
is one for the books
User Avatar
Mercenaire

  1. first 2)Mh, probably not.
  2. I don't really see the whole ponytail part? Maybe make them more pronounced? (although I said I preffered the first one and the second has them more pronounced).

art by
[flower=pac]

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Country
is emotional
User Avatar
Muzic

  1. The first one
  2. If I'm not broke YES... you keep me broke...
  3. I like it how it is, super duper cute!

[Item=spotted hyena in a box]

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar

!!

Oh. I think it's because it's not called ponytail -- but pigtail. LOL

Sorry, it's just me failing at English again. xD

Thanks ❤

Thank you! I'm super taking this in consideration xD

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Pac
is one for the books
User Avatar
Mercenaire

Oh... Those are the same thing in my head :o What's the difference?

art by
[flower=pac]

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar

ponytail: a way of arranging hair by gathering it together at the back of the head and letting it hang down freely

pigtail: a length of hair that is tied at the back of the head or at each side of the head

THANKS GOOGLE ❤

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Vars
is entitled
User Avatar
Guy Fieri

  1. the 2nd! i like the bangs and the pigtails more on that one
  2. YEA im fussy w/ colours tho so dont like bank on me as a human being slotting just in case
  3. i like the top of the 2nd one and the bottom of the 1st, where in the 1st it doesn't cover as much of the hand/arm sort of if that makes sense! its literally like barely a difference tho but tbh that's all

HOPEFULLY THAT HELPS IDK

[box=#fff]
tumblr signature by [/box]

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Exie
is a book worm
User Avatar
  1. Which one do you like the most? 2

  2. Would you be interested in slotting on any of them in the future? Yes, your stuff is always lovely. Some day i hope to buy most of your stuff when i get some money.

  3. What could I change to make it better? Like said maybe make them more pronounced so that you can actually tell they are pigtails. But i think number 2 is lovely.

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
sakura
is starry-eyed
User Avatar

i liek the first WIP better for a lot of resons: the bang style, the shape of the pigtails as they come over the chest, the overall shape... my main critique as that it could be pretty hard to layer with the hair covering the HA's right (our left) shoulder - maybe instead of the hair coming IN to cover that side of the chest, have it coming away from it? also, i can see there might be some potential perspective issues, namely the hair part seems intended to be in the middle but it actually veers off to (our) left i can't say yet if i'd be interested in picking up a version of this wig cos of how rough it is currently, but i think i'd be able to say so more definitively as it's finalized!

Mar 16, 2017 9 years ago
Feline
is unlucky
User Avatar
Salvadore

1 - The first one, the way the hair falls around the face feels more natural to me 2 - Sadly long wigs are not my cup of tea, I find it hard to work with any hair that falls below the shoulders, so unfortunately I wouldn't be slotting. 3 - It took my awhile to notice where the hair was tied for the pigtails, maybe make the hair ties just a teeny bit bigger?

Fancy Feline: CW Thread ~ Ping Group ~ CW Shop

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar

That was actually super helpful because I wasn't thinking on how hard it could be for layering. I usually avoid wigs that cover the chest much, but since I'm comission this one to be somewhat of a tribute, I think that I ignored that detail for a little and I should super consider it! Thank you ;-;

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar

Also, do you think that the hair failling on the left HA shoulder is okay or will also be a pain to layer? ;-;

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
shylarah
is a Time Lord
User Avatar
Yahrzeit

I like the first one better personally. The second feels too wide, in my opinion. If you want to have the wider pigtails, make the rest of the hair less, in the lower untied part, and perhaps put a gap in there near where they tie. The bangs feel like they fit better in the first, though perhaps the second does them better towards the middle of the forehead. there's something slightly odd about how it falls around the shoulders, since the pigtails are farther back on the head but come in front, plus unbound hair from even farther back is in front of the shoulder, but...I can't quite put my finger on what bothers me, nor on how to fix it.

I think the first one is adorable, and actually I /love/ that color, though I am looking for different types of styles in it, not one like this so much. The style idea itself is lovely, but I don't think I can justify buying one.

The way some people spell makes me wonder about their pronunciation. My CW shop, and my ping group

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Organ Donor
BadWidget
User Avatar
Serneria

  1. The first one, the bangs are better imo.

  2. Probably not, I tend to like wigs with exaggerated details.

  3. I'm not like CRAZY about the bangs as is. Maybe something like this? as far as the bangs go.

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar

OMG

THAT WIG IS SO PRECIOUS

I TOTALLY SAVED IT FOR A FUTURE COMISSION

thank you ;-;

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Organ Donor
BadWidget
User Avatar
Serneria

LOL, glad to be of service....also....i'll be stalking that future commission XD

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
sakura
is starry-eyed
User Avatar

i think that one should be fine! generally if you have one shoulder covering vs both (with long hair) it's at least manageable and can lead to some rly cute looks

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Pac
is one for the books
User Avatar
Mercenaire

Oh, fair enough XD Well good luck in any case :*

(and I agree about layering)

art by
[flower=pac]

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Vanessa
has LOTS of clothes
User Avatar
  1. Which one do you like the most? First one

  2. Would you be interested in slotting on any of them in the future? (consider only the style here, ignore the color) Yep. You did say to ignore the color, but I'd only slot on it if certain colors get released (though I might not since I'm broke af atm, lol... too many slots to pay for)

  3. What could I change to make it better? I'd second sakura's suggestion!

(Also, out of curiosity, it is a tribute to what?)

[center]

Mar 17, 2017 9 years ago
Lyonesse
is custom made
User Avatar
Please log in to reply to this topic.