Preferably under 10k because I am a mega cheapskate tbh, but stuff like the Shed Erdoo Tooth -- i.e. things I can layer and have them be the main focus, obvious bodily deformations/mutations -- are what I'm looking for!

I would suggest looking through the Morostide and Survival item lists on Subeta HQ or a similar site. Most of the body horror items I regularly use came from those events.

, Subeta HQ doesn't work anymore and SubetaLodge doesn't show wearable previews without going to individual pages :(

lucky for you i have actiually sorted these things in a seperate wardarobe drawer. lets see...

and other Rubber Monster Gloves and masks and others from the 2010 tab in the zombie den[item=Yellow Rubber Insect Pincer (Left Hand)]and other colors and other colors most of the cheap stuff however is more monster like. Alternatively you could have a look at Rachelle's for monstery limb overlays 10k apiece