I bought [item2=Mistletwirl] from the MC last night, but have been unable to remove it from my WL. Every time I click "Remove From Wishlist", the text option to "Remove From Wishlist" is still there. I waited until today to try again, but am still having this problem. I have not had this problem with any other items.

Did you happen to accidentally add doubles of it to your WL? There was a major issue during the whole WL problems with the lag causing people to add multiples of the same item to their WL. You might have to go in and delete those manually if that's what happened.

Thank you for the suggestion! I just went in and checked and only saw it in there once. Funny enough, I clicked on it in my items and it looks like it's no longer on my WL. I guess someone is working on it :)

It may have only been added a handful of times and you managed to get it down to once by clicking - Wishlist. I know I ended up with 20+ of an item on my WL from that though, when the MC/Quest Shops switched to their winter stock lol. Glad you got it fixed though! ^_^

That might have been what happened! I clicked on it a bunch of times last night trying to get it off of there haha. I thought maybe there was something wrong with the item!