Like, Library = books, Wizard = Tokens, Sag = money... I'm specifically looking for collectibles like plushies, beanbags, trading cards, etc.

Hmm Cinthia and Maleria only give me money, I think the other ones give you random items (except Quentin, because she gives you almost the same items everyday)

Library and Pete have a good random chance of giving you a random collectable items.

As far as I know.

I get pretty expensive items from Quentin everyday.