I just gifted someone and the gift isn't showing in my list of gifts given. This happened once last week too. Will they get the gift or did it poof ?
(Just realised this is in completely the wrong thread sorry >< )
In case you got a long list of given gifts, did you try searching with Ctrl F on their username? I saw that users who didn't collect their tree gifts last year appear at the bottom of the list, and if I gave them an extra gift now, they remained at the bottom of the list, they didn't get added to the top of "newest" gifts.
You are a genius! I hadn't even thought of that. I did a Ctrl + F and there they were way at the bottom with last years gifts, plus this years gifts listed. Welp I guess they're getting double from me this year. Than you so much for your help! =D