I love this thread and find it super useful. The old one was FULL (over 7k posts) so I'm starting it back!

Simply rate the above HA (1 being "bad" and 10 being "perfect")

And then give a suggestion on how it could come across better or improve :) Feel free to suggest items or color combos for their HA as well.

8.5/10 Your HA is so very charming! I think the gloves might need to be layered behind the skirt as the right one looks a bit off. Maybe a slightly less bright shade of hair?

7/10 Interesting concept, but I'm not feeling all of it. Mostly, the color blending is throwing me off- the greens are beautiful, while the reds are very much in your face. So suggestion wise- more green towards the top of your HA, and perhaps a softer red corset top?

10/10

I adore the color scheme here and I love the "Snow White" feel I'm getting from it!

One small suggestion, I can't tell for sure but it looks like the earrings may be layered on top of the hair and not behind. That's seriously the only thing I can think of :)

: 9/10

Because I don't give perfect marks. But +50pts to whatever house you're in because that username is EVERYTHING.

The HA is very cute but I feel that the background would be better plain or with a different backdrop. :)

[-at-miffy]

Probably 8/10 I like your avatar, and I see what you're doing, but the bluegreen of the clasp, the embellishment on the dress and the eye color really throw off the whole effect for me.

8/10 I love the color of your top! I feel the you balanced the black pretty well, could use just a little more white towards the bottom.

7/10 Beautiful HA! However, it feels like it is missing something. I think adding a bg would help with that.

8.5/10

Those eyes look wonderful! <3 Her arm seems is a bit...naked, though. Maybe some simple jewelry for the arm and/or neck would add a nice finishing touch C:

8/10 you have a lot of these reds that match perfectly but then the hair is a different shade so it feels a bit off; i would suggest either matching the hair to one of the colors already in the outfit, or going for a different natural color.

7/10 I like the overall look that you're going for here, she looks hella fierce. The only suggestion I can think of is maybe different shoes? The ones you have on just feel a little overwhelmed by the tights. Really cool HA though!

rating above!! i love the wig and the flowers above...I'm not so sure about the pink background look...if you added more pink to your avatar maybe it would go better...like a couple pink things maybe pink shoes or a pink top. Other wise i like the wig 8/10 whats it called??? tell me what you think about mine! I keep trying to change it up and have a color coordination going on.

8/10 I think you did a fantastic job of matching the colors of the outfit with the printed pants. My only comment would be that the flowers in the hair, especially the daisies, seem really out of place with the outfit and makes the head seem too heavy. Maybe find something that's more of a cloth or ribbon? Or even something winter themed to tie in.

I like this, especially the details on the arm, but the layering of the scarf and dress are a bit weird to me - they're both definitely difficult to use imo. The dark blue on the scarf doesn't match anything else but it looks good, so maybe change out the dress; there's a lot of options. Also maybe add earrings or something with the ankles, depends on how simple you want to keep it. 7/10!

your outfit is so well-blended and the colors match perfectly. I'm kinda new so I dont know if that is all part of a set or not, but the feel is very calm and serene and overall well done.

The only thing i'd add are more accessories to match the brown-goldish on the mask and eyes, otherwise its fab! Also I'd personally add some kind of foreground or background, but that's more of my personal choice. 8.5/10!

Your outfit as a excellent color scheme. The use of Jewelry is amazing and simple (In a good way!) Though the eyes kind of puts me at a halt. I love the idea and it is amazingly put together. Maybe try a more round eye? (Just a suggestion!) 9.5/10! Well done!

6.5/10 I think the eye makeup is a bit much. I don't think this jacket layers particularly well with the skirt, it just doesn't make sense to me. The belt also just randomly cuts off, poofy skirts can be a bit harder to layer sometimes.

Really love this! 9/10 maybe add some peach shoes or something?

I love it! Not sure if this is a particular character in Dr. Who, I'm so behind, but it's beautiful regardless. And I especially like the background + the TARDIS; Van Gogh's storyline was soooo beautiful and touching in the show and the swirls on the police box go so well with the background, it's a very touching tribute :) However, the shirt/sleeves don't seem to fit in with the rest of the kooky fan vibe. Maybe change the goggles to something a bit prettier/more refined, or else add a jacket or something instead of those graceful, lovely sleeves. 8/10, but 10/10 for the thoughtful background!

I love it! The scarecrow is really clever and I like how you did a steampunk owl instead of a crow! I am assuming it is wizard of oz? I will give it a 9/10! Not sure what the little things on the hat are like patches?